Life Cycle Assessment of Dry Sewage Sludge Handling Methods for the State of Kuwait

Y. Almuzaini

Abstract:This study provides investigations for the most environmentally friendly option for dry sludge handling methods to assist decision makers in the Sanitary Department in the Ministry of Public Works in the State of Kuwait. The results can be a useful guide for project planners and designers in the sludge treatment plants sector. Incineration, landfill and land application of dry sludge were compared from an LCA perspective. Using dry sewage sludge in land application to fertilize forage grass is the best option in this study because this option will utilize the dry sewage sludge instead of wasting it and minimize the cost of importing more amounts of fertilizers and for the following reasons: 1) Land application of dry sewage sludge has the least impact on global warming because the released CH4, N2O and CO2 emissions are less than the incineration and landfill scenarios. 2) The least number of particulates (such as least PM < 2.5 µm, SO2) that contribute to particulate matter formation are released during the land application of sewage sludge. 3) The land application scenario has the least amount of released lead and zinc that contribute to the human non-carcinogenic category. 4) In the land application scenario, the amounts of nickel and chromium VI that cause human carcinogenic toxicity are less than in the incineration and landfill scenarios. 5) The land application scenario has the least values for the substances (SO2, ammonia and NOx) which lead to terrestrial acidification. 6) Land application of dry sewage sludge consumes fewer minerals such as nickel, phosphorus and iron than the landfill and incineration scenarios. 7) Land application consumed the least amounts of natural gas and crude oil among the scenarios and has the least impact on fossil resource scarcity. 8) Land application of dry sewage sludge has the least amount of terrestrial ecotoxicity, which is caused by zinc, vanadium, nickel, lead, copper and cadmium. 9) The amount of damage caused by N2O, NOx and NMVOC in the land application scenario is less than the amount of damage caused by these substances in the landfill and incineration scenarios. In other words, land application has the least impact on ozone depletion and ozone formation. In the land application scenario, open loop recycling means that the resultant dry sewage sludge from the wastewater treatment process is reused, and the N, P and K nutrients of dry sewage sludge are recycled and brought back to the soil to act as fertilizers. The concept of open loop recycling of sewage sludge postpones the disposal options by converting the dry sludge into new materials that can be used to produce fertilizers, maintains materials (such as N, P and K) in the soil for longer duration and restricts the need for new raw material to be consumed from nature. The impacts of the incineration and the landfill scenarios are having almost the same impacts values in all indicators. The reason behind the similarity was the negligible influence of the facilities used in the incineration and landfill scenarios. The contribution percentage of both the municipal solid waste incineration plant (used in the incineration scenario) and the municipal landfill facility (used in the landfill scenario) selected from the Ecoinvent 3.0 database is less than 1%. 6.2 Recommendations An economic analysis associated with social evaluation should be included with the environmental assessment in future work to provide a more sustainable conclusion. One concern about the findings was that the transportation process was excluded from the system boundaries. Based on the research findings, the study suggests for the wastewater and sludge treatment sector in the State of Kuwait to comply with the required allowable limits of heavy metals, organic compounds concentrations, annual pollutant loading rates and cumulative pollutant loading rates of the dry sewage sludge in order to be used in agricultural and land application purposes. SimaPro is a highly used piece of LCA software that is thoroughly tested and robust. As well, SimaPro's findings, charts and reports are easy to share and export. The hardware and software requirements for running SimaPro are fairly light. SimaPro life cycle analysis software can calculate a carbon footprint of many kinds of products and systems. SimaPro can determine the potential environmental impact that a system produces with statistical accuracy Using Monte Carlo statistical method. On the other hand, to run this LCA software, you have to use Windows. If you use SimaPro through an emulator on any other native operating system, the stability is potentially an issue and there is no support for any operating system other than Windows. It is necessary for every device running SimaPro on a server to have 5 GB of hard drive space.

Environmental Science