Abstract:Long-distance power transmission is a very important way of energy utilization, which can achieve regional environmental benefits through the transfer of air pollutants. But, how to evaluate such benefits has not been well presented. This study uses a generalized approach to assess the environmental and health benefits of power transmission based on the GAINS model. The impact pathway approach is adopted to evaluate the health losses in the electric power industry. The epidemiological relative risk is calculated by integrated exposure-response function. An inter-regional health loss impact matrix is constructed to reflect indirect effects due to the regional diffusion of air pollution. Using the case of China, this study evaluates whether the current ultra-high voltage (UHV) power transmission lines can bring environmental and health benefits, and discusses in which provinces the establishment of electricity interconnection can bring more benefits. The results highlight the importance of considering air quality, pollutant diffusion, and health losses in environmental benefit assessment, which is significantly different from the results obtained by using air pollutant emissions alone. Most UHV direct current lines can bring high environmental and health benefits, but the performances of UHV alternating current lines are relatively poor. The power transmission from Northwest China, Southwest China, and Inner Mongolia to Central China can bring relatively large environmental and health benefits, which may become a direction for future long-distance power transmission planning.
environmental sciences,green & sustainable science & technology,engineering, environmental
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve
This paper aims to evaluate whether Ultra High Voltage (UHV) transmission lines in China can bring environmental and health benefits. Specifically, the study assesses the impact of long-distance power transmission on air pollution transfer, environmental improvement, and human health through a comprehensive approach. The paper focuses on the following aspects:
1. **Environmental Benefit Assessment**:
- Assess how power transmission via UHV lines affects the emission of air pollutants in different regions.
- Consider the dispersion of air pollutants in different regions and their impact on the environment.
2. **Health Loss Assessment**:
- Calculate the damage to human health from exposure to PM2.5 concentrations using epidemiological relative risk (RR).
- Construct a cross-regional health loss impact matrix to reflect the indirect effects brought by the dispersion of air pollution.
3. **Comprehensive Evaluation Method**:
- Use the GAINS model to simulate the emission of air pollutants and changes in air quality.
- Apply the impact pathway approach to assess the direct and indirect health losses caused by the power industry.
- Calculate changes in health external costs using economic valuation methods.
### Main Contributions
1. **Proposed a General Method** to assess the environmental benefits of power transmission from the perspective of air quality and human health.
2. **Considered the Regional Dispersion of Air Pollution**, incorporating indirect environmental and health effects.
3. **Provided a New Perspective** to reveal the true value of UHV lines by assessing environmental externalities, aiding in the planning of future cross-regional power interconnection networks.
### Research Background
- **Importance of Power Transmission**: Power transmission is an important way of energy utilization that can achieve regional environmental benefits by transferring air pollutants.
- **Development of UHV Technology**: China is one of the fastest-developing countries in UHV technology. By 2019, the State Grid Corporation had built 20 UHV transmission lines, and the China Southern Power Grid Company had built 3.
- **Limitations of Existing Research**: Many studies mainly focus on the economic benefits of long-distance power transmission, CO2 reduction, water resource savings, and renewable energy development, but neglect environmental impacts, especially on human health.
### Research Methods
- **GAINS Model**: Used to simulate the emission of air pollutants and changes in air quality.
- **Air Pollution Emission Calculation**: Calculate emission factors based on the power generation technology and terminal pollution control technology in each region.
- **Health Loss Assessment**: Calculate the damage to human health from PM2.5 concentrations using epidemiological methods, with Years of Life Lost (YLL) as an indicator.
- **Economic Valuation**: Calculate changes in health external costs based on YLL and the Value of a Life Year (VOLY).
### Results and Discussion
- **Environmental Benefits**: Most UHV DC lines can reduce the emission of air pollutants, with significant effects in Xinjiang and Sichuan. However, a few lines may lead to an overall increase in pollutant emissions, such as Shanxi-Jiangsu and Xilin Gol-Taizhou.
- **Health Loss**: The environmental benefits of UHV AC lines are poor, especially in coal-producing areas such as Inner Mongolia, Shanxi, and Shaanxi, where coal-fired power generation is predominant.
- **Economic Valuation**: By calculating changes in health external costs, the environmental and health benefits of UHV lines are further verified.
### Conclusion
This study emphasizes the importance of considering air quality, pollutant dispersion, and health losses when assessing the environmental benefits of power transmission. The proposed comprehensive evaluation method reveals the limitations of assessing environmental benefits solely based on air pollutant emissions and provides a new perspective for the planning of future cross-regional power interconnection networks.