Abstract:Congenitally deaf individuals exhibit enhanced visuospatial abilities relative to normally hearing individuals. An early example is the increased sensitivity of deaf signers to stimuli in the visual periphery (Neville and Lawson, 1987a). While these enhancements are robust and extend across a number of visual and spatial skills, they seem not to extend to other domains which could potentially build on these enhancements. For example, congenitally deaf children, in the absence of adequate language exposure and acquisition, do not develop typical social cognition skills as measured by traditional Theory of Mind tasks. These delays/deficits occur despite their presumed lifetime use of visuo-perceptual abilities to infer the intentions and behaviors of others (e.g., Pyers and Senghas, 2009; O'Reilly et al., 2014). In a series of studies, we explore the limits on the plasticity of visually based socio-cognitive abilities, from perspective taking to Theory of Mind/False Belief, in rarely studied individuals: deaf <i>adults</i> who have not acquired a conventional language (Homesigners). We compared Homesigners' performance to that of two other understudied groups in the same culture: Deaf signers of an emerging language (Cohort 1 of Nicaraguan Sign Language), and hearing speakers of Spanish with minimal schooling. We found that homesigners performed equivalently to both comparison groups with respect to several visual socio-cognitive abilities: Perspective Taking (Levels 1 and 2), adapted from Masangkay et al. (1974), and the False Photograph task, adapted from Leslie and Thaiss (1992). However, a lifetime of visuo-perceptual experiences (observing the behavior and interactions of others) did <i>not</i> support success on False Belief tasks, even when linguistic demands were minimized. Participants in the comparison groups outperformed the Homesigners, but did not universally pass the False Belief tasks. Our results suggest that while some of the social development achievements of young typically developing children may be dissociable from their linguistic experiences, language and/or educational experiences clearly scaffolds the transition into False Belief understanding. The lack of experience using a shared language cannot be overcome, even with the benefit of many years of observing others' behaviors and the potential neural reorganization and visuospatial enhancements resulting from deafness.

Validating Silent Gesture Lab Studies in a Naturally Emerging Sign Language: How Order is Used to Describe Intensional Versus Extensional Events in Nicaraguan Sign Language

Facing and challenging language ideologies towards a more inclusive understanding of language in mathematics education research—the case of sign languages

From Seed to System: The Emergence of Non-Manual Markers for Wh-Questions in Nicaraguan Sign Language

More Than Looks: Exploring Methods to Test Phonological Discrimination in the Sign Language Kata Kolok

Using the Hands to Represent Objects in Space: Gesture as a Substrate for Signed Language Acquisition

Homesign Research, Gesture Studies, and Sign Language Linguistics: The Bigger Picture of Homesign and Homesigners

Translanguaging and the No Voice Policy in L2 Sign Language Contexts

Visible Social Interactions Do Not Support the Development of False Belief Understanding in the Absence of Linguistic Input: Evidence from Deaf Adult Homesigners

Learning a language from inconsistent input: Regularization in child and adult learners

Searching for Structure: Investigating Emergent Communication with Large Language Models

Gesture is the primary modality for language creation

Embodiment, linguistics, space: American Sign Language meets geography

New Perspectives on the Neurobiology of Sign Languages

Examining Gesture Production in the Presence of Communication Challenges

Comparing Native Signing, Late-Signing and Orally Trained Deaf Children's ‘Theory of Mind’ Abilities

Why Second Language Acquisition of sign languages matters to general SLA research

Challenges for Linguistically-Driven Computer-Based Sign Recognition from Continuous Signing for American Sign Language

Language as Description, Indication, and Depiction

Tutorial: Sign Language Linguistics

Signalling games, sociolinguistic variation and the construction of style

Spoken Language Activation Alters Subsequent Sign Language Activation in L2 Learners of American Sign Language