Abstract:In this study, we analyze how customer perceptions of ex ante unfairness affect a service provider that offers a priority service option. Customers differ in their waiting time costs, but that information is private to each customer. To address this issue and maximize revenue, the service provider offers a regular queue and a priority queue with an additional fee, thereby inducing the self‐selection of customers into those two queues. The customers make their service‐joining decision, based on the publicized queue terms, before entering the queue. In such a service system, the priority customers pay to reduce their waiting time, which increases the average waiting time for regular customers, as compared with a “first come, first served” (FCFS) queue. This increase in the waiting time can lead to a perception of unfairness by the regular customers. In this paper, we model this ex ante unfairness perception as a negative utility for the regular customers that is proportional to the difference in the expected waiting times between the segmented regular queue and a nonsegmented FCFS queueing system and investigate the service provider's optimal decisions regarding segmentation and pricing. We find that, in a service system where customers can balk, the service provider should focus on only one service offering through a lower priority fee or differentiated services under certain conditions and charge a higher priority fee once the perception of unfairness is taken into consideration. An equilibrium sensitivity study provides guidance on how best to design, construct, and operate queues. Finally, we examine two extension cases in which (1) the customer ex ante unfairness perception is defined as proportional to the waiting time difference between regular and priority queues or (2) priority customers exhibit either a “negative ex ante unfairness perception” or “positive ex ante unfairness perception” of queueing. Our results are robust, and we identify conditions under which a heightened unfairness perception could be beneficial or detrimental to the service provider.

The Effects of Queue Structure on Attitudes

How Long Did I Wait? the Effect of Construal Levels on Consumers' Wait Duration Judgments

Read into the Lines: the Positive Effects of Queues

The Effect of Queuing Technology on Customer Experience in Physical Retail Environments

Waiting for Public Transport Services: Queueing Analysis with Balking and Reneging Behaviors of Impatient Passengers

Designing Worthy Waiting Spaces: A Cross-Cultural Study of Waiting Room Features and Their Impact on Women's Affective States

A survey of queueing systems with strategic timing of arrivals

Customer Segmentation and Ex Ante Fairness: A Queueing Perspective

When the medium massages perceptions: Personal (vs. public) displays of information reduce crowding perceptions and outsider mistreatment of frontline staff.

The non-preemptive 'Join the Shortest Queue–Serve the Longest Queue' service system with or without switch-over times

Psychological effects of perceived crowding on time displacement behavior: mediating roles of perceived control loss and negative emotion, moderated by perceived waiting time

Balancing Herding and Congestion in Service Systems: a Queueing Perspective

The effects of impatience from waiting in line on choice overload

Chronicles of jockeying in queuing systems

Pricing decision of service systems based on the combined effect of multiple customer psychology

Optimal and Self Selection of Service Type in a Queueing System where Long Service Postpones the Need for the Next Service

Managing online wait: Designing effective waiting screens across cultures

Optimal Queue Design

Queueing Systems with Preferred Service Delivery Times and Multiple Customer Classes

Waiting in intertemporal choice tasks affects discounting and subjective time perception.

Crowds in front of bottlenecks at entrances from the perspective of physics and social psychology