Abstract:We investigate computational and mechanism design aspects of scarce resource allocation, where the primary rationing mechanism is through waiting times. Specifically we consider allocating medical treatments to a population of patients. Each patient needs exactly one treatment, and can choose from $k$ hospitals. Hospitals have different costs, which are fully paid by a third party ---the "payer". The payer has a fixed budget $B$, and each hospital will have its own waiting time. At equilibrium, each patient will choose his most preferred hospital given his intrinsic preferences and the waiting times. The payer thus computes the waiting times so that at equilibrium the budget constraint is satisfied and the social welfare is maximized. We first show that the optimization problem is NP-hard, yet if the budget can be relaxed to $(1+\epsilon)B$ for an arbitrarily small $\epsilon$, then the optimum under budget $B$ can be approximated efficiently. Next, we study the endogenous emergence of waiting time from the dynamics between hospitals and patients, and show that there is no need for the payer to explicitly enforce the optimal waiting times. Under certain conditions, all he need is to enforce the amount of money he wants to pay to each hospital. The dynamics will always converge to the desired waiting times in finite time. We then go beyond equilibrium solutions and investigate the optimization problem over a much larger class of mechanisms containing the equilibrium ones as special cases. With two hospitals, we show that under a natural assumption on the patients' preference profiles, optimal welfare is in fact attained by the randomized assignment mechanism, which allocates patients to hospitals at random subject to the budget constraint, but avoids waiting times. Finally, we discuss potential policy implications of our results, as well as follow-up directions and open problems.

Optimal Queue Design

Optimal and Self Selection of Service Type in a Queueing System where Long Service Postpones the Need for the Next Service

Balancing Herding and Congestion in Service Systems: a Queueing Perspective

Optimal control of a queueing system

A Characterization of Optimal Queueing Regimes

Optimum and equilibrium in a transport problem with queue effects

Optimum Bribing for Queue Position

Optimal Intensity Allocation of Single-Server Queueing Networks

Optimal Provision-After-Wait in Healthcare

Editorial on Advanced Road Traffic Control

Queueing Systems with Preferred Service Delivery Times and Multiple Customer Classes

Structural Properties of Optimal Fidelity Selection Policies for Human-in-the-loop Queues

Optimal Allocation via Waitlists: Simplicity Through Information Design

Age-Delay Tradeoffs in Queueing Systems

A survey of queueing systems with strategic timing of arrivals

How to Schedule Near-Optimally under Real-World Constraints

Learning a Discrete Set of Optimal Allocation Rules in a Queueing System with Unknown Service Rate

Optimal intensity control of a queueing system with state-dependent capacity limit

Stabilizing a Queue Subject to Action-Dependent Server Performance

Deciding Which Queue to Join: Some Counterexamples

A Complete Algebraic Solution to the Optimal Dynamic Rationing Policy in the Stock-Rationing Queue with Two Demand Classes