Is "capitalism" a misnomer?: on Marx's "capitalism" and knight's "civilization"

David Ellerman
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09672567.2024.2364653
2024-06-12
European Journal of the History of Economic Thought
Abstract:The name "capitalism" derives from Marx's false analogy between medieval land ownership and the "ownership of the means of production." However, unlike medieval land, capital goods can be rented out, e.g., by Frank Knight's entrepreneur, and then the capital owner does not hold those management or product rights. What then is the characteristic institution in our civilization? It is the voluntary renting of workers. What then is the relationship between Classical Liberalism, the dominant philosophy behind Economics, and a lifetime labour contract? Frank Knight had plenty to say about the doctrine of inalienable rights which disallows such contracts.
economics,history of social sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Address This paper attempts to explore whether the term "capitalism" is a misnomer. The author, David Ellerman, believes that the name "capitalism" originates from Marx's erroneous analogy between medieval land ownership and modern ownership of means of production. Marx limited capital and its private ownership as the core of the "capitalist" system, but this analogy is not accurate. Specifically, the paper explores the following points: 1. **Marx's Erroneous Analogy**: Marx made an analogy between medieval land ownership and modern ownership of means of production, believing that capital owners have management and product ownership rights over laborers. However, modern capital goods can be leased out, which means that capital owners do not necessarily hold these management or product rights. 2. **Voluntary Employment Relationship**: The paper points out that a significant feature of modern society is that workers can be voluntarily leased, employed, or rented, rather than being permanently owned as in slavery. This voluntary employment relationship is an important feature of the modern economic system, rather than the ownership of capital. 3. **Classical Liberalism and Lifetime Contracts**: The paper also discusses the attitude of classical liberalism towards voluntary lifetime labor contracts. Although classical liberals emphasize that voluntariness is a necessary condition for the legitimacy of social institutions, they have differing views on voluntary lifetime labor contracts. Some classical liberals believe that such contracts are immoral because they violate basic human freedom rights. In summary, the paper attempts to reveal the true characteristics of the modern economic system by re-examining the term "capitalism" and suggests that "voluntary employment relationship" or "human rental system" might be a more accurate description.