Abstract:Quantitative characterization of the health impacts associated with exposure to chemical mixtures has received considerable attention in current environmental and epidemiological studies. With many existing statistical methods and emerging approaches, it is important for practitioners to understand when each method is best suited for their inferential goals. In this study, we conduct a review and comparison of 11 analytical methods available for use in mixtures research, through extensive simulation studies for continuous and binary outcomes. These methods fall in three different classes: identifying important components of a mixture, identifying interactions and creating a summary score for risk stratification and prediction. We carry out an illustrative data analysis in the PROTECT birth cohort from Puerto Rico. Most importantly we develop an integrated package “CompMix” that provides a platform for mixtures analysis where the practitioner can implement a pipeline for several types of mixtures analysis. Our simulation results suggest that the choice of methods depends on the goal of analysis and there is no clear winner across the board. For selection of important toxicants in the mixture and for identifying interactions, Elastic net by Zou et al. (Enet), Lasso for Hierarchical Interactions by Bien et al (HierNet), Selection of nonlinear interactions by a forward stepwise algorithm by Narisetty et al. (SNIF) have the most stable performance across simulation settings. Additionally, the predictive performance of the Super Learner ensembling method by Van de Laan et al. and HierNet are found to be superior to the rest of the methods. For overall summary or a cumulative measure, we find that using the Super Learner to combine multiple Environmental Risk Scores can lead to improved risk stratification properties. We have developed an R package “CompMix: A comprehensive toolkit for environmental mixtures analysis”, allowing users to implement a variety of tasks under different settings and compare the findings. In summary, our study offers guidelines for selecting appropriate statistical methods for addressing specific scientific questions related to mixtures research. We identify critical gaps where new and better methods are needed.

Estimation and false discovery control for the analysis of environmental mixtures

A permutation-based approach to inference for weighted sum regression with correlated chemical mixtures

Accommodating detection limits of multiple exposures in environmental mixture analyses: an overview of statistical approaches

Estimating the health effects of environmental mixtures using Bayesian semiparametric regression and sparsity inducing priors

A Comparison of Statistical Methods for Studying Interactions of Chemical Mixtures

Inferring Synergistic and Antagonistic Interactions in Mixtures of Exposures

Two-step approach for assessing the health effects of environmental chemical mixtures: application to simulated datasets and real data from the Navajo Birth Cohort Study

Causal Analysis of Air Pollution Mixtures: Estimands, Positivity, and Extrapolation

Sensitivity analysis with multiple treatments and multiple outcomes with applications to air pollution mixtures

Statistical methods for chemical mixtures: a roadmap for practitioners

Detecting Shape-Based Interactions Among Environmental Chemicals Using an Ensemble of Exposure-Mixture Regression and Interpretable Machine Learning Tools

Environmental Exposure Mixtures: Questions and Methods to Address Them

Incorporating biological knowledge in analyses of environmental mixtures and health

Environmental Mixtures Analysis (E-MIX) Workflow and Methods Repository

A review of practical statistical methods used in epidemiological studies to estimate the health effects of multi-pollutant mixture

A quantile-based g-computation approach to addressing the effects of exposure mixtures

Bayesian multiple index models for environmental mixtures

Estimation and Inference for Case-Control Studies with Multiple Non-Gold Standard Exposure Assessments: with an Occupational Health Application.

Optimal False Discovery Rate Control for Large Scale Multiple Testing with Auxiliary Information

A Mixture Model Based Approach for Estimating the FDR in Replicated Microarray Data