Abstract:Abstract This article aims to review the development of acoustic computer simulation for performance spaces. The databases of Web of Science and Scopus were searched for peer-reviewed journal articles published in English between 1960 and 2021, using the keywords for “simulation”, “acoustic”, “performance space”, “measure”, and their synonyms. The inclusion criteria were as follows: (1) the searched article should be focused on the field of room acoustics (reviews were excluded); (2) a computer simulation algorithm should be used; (3) it should be clearly stated that the simulated object is a performance space; and (4) acoustic measurements should be used for comparison with the simulation. Finally, twenty studies were included. A standardised data extraction form was used to collect the modelling information, software/algorithm, indicators for comparison, and other information. The results revealed that the most used acoustic indicators were early decay time (EDT), reverberation time ( T 30 ), strength ( G ), and definition ( D 50 ). The accuracy of these indicators differed greatly. For non-iterative simulation, the simulation accuracies of most indicators were outside their respective just noticeable differences. Although a larger sample size was required for further validation, simulations of T 30 , EDT, and D 50 all showed an increase in accuracy with increasing time from 1979 to 2020, except for G . In terms of frequency, the simulation was generally less accurate at lower frequencies, which occurred at T 30 , G, D 50 and T 20 . However, EDT accuracy did not exhibit significant frequency sensitivity. The prediction accuracy of inter-aural cross-correlation coefficients (IACC) was even higher at low frequencies than it was at high frequencies. The average value of most indicators showed a clear systematic deviation from zero, providing hints for future algorithm improvements. Limitations and the risks of bias in this review were discussed. Finally, various types of benchmark tests were suggested for various comparison goals.

Impulse response of the Bayreuth Festspielhaus

Acoustics of Margravial Opera House Bayreuth

A method to virtually extend reverberation time of measured impulse responses without losing room coloration

A Method for Capturing and Reproducing Directional Reverberation in Six Degrees of Freedom

A hybrid room acoustic modeling approach combining image source, acoustic diffusion equation, and time-domain discontinuous Galerkin methods

Room acoustic computer modeling—A case study to compare industry standard software with measured results

On the relevance of acoustic measurements for creating realistic virtual acoustic environments

Computationally-efficient and perceptually-motivated rendering of diffuse reflections in room acoustics simulation

Evaluating acoustical qualities of four rooms using questionnaires

Calibrating the Sabine and Eyring formulas

Reconstruction of the reverberation theory in a diffuse sound field by using reflection orders

Estimation of Source and Receiver Positions, Room Geometry and Reflection Coefficients From a Single Room Impulse Response

Real-time auralization for performers on virtual stages

Dataset of Spatial Room Impulse Responses in a Variable Acoustics Room for Six Degrees-of-Freedom Rendering and Analysis

Uncertainties of Reverberation Time Estimation Via Adaptively Identified Room Impulse Responses.

Outdoor Concert Hotel Acoustics

Spatial aspects of reproduced sound in small rooms

Listener perception of changes in historically informed performance of solo baroque music due to room acoustics

Spatial resolution of late reverberation in virtual acoustic environments

Development of acoustic computer simulation for performance spaces: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Coherent active methods for applications in room acoustics