Cross-cultural Research of Speech Codes: Transitivity Processes in Corporate Social Responsibility Reports
Feihong Gai,Lianrui Yang,Shifa Chen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/21582440241240861
IF: 2.032
2024-04-12
SAGE Open
Abstract:Sage Open, Volume 14, Issue 2, April-June 2024. Evolving from ethnographic research that determines what meanings are shared within a culture, studies regarding Speech Codes Theory have been conducted with implications for intercultural communication. Arguing for transitivity as speech codes in diverse cultures, this paper aims to describe and explain the transitivity attributes of English-medium Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) reports by Chinese and British/American corporations, and the transitivity variances between industries by Chinese corporations. Results reveal that frequencies of transitivity features in the Chinese CSR reports are significantly lower than those in the British/American reports, and that the relational process dominates in the corpus under investigation. Also, cross-industrial comparisons among Chinese corporations show that the mechanical manufacturing enterprises and the iron & steel enterprises share similar transitivity codes, but they differ from the energy enterprises distinctively. The paper concludes that linguistic/cultural contexts, translation strategies, moves in the CSR reports, and industry attributes together contribute to the transitivity codes and communicative conducts in different cultural and industrial backgrounds. This paper might help writers/translators of CSR reports in China better understand lexical and functional conformities and peculiarities reflected in Chinese and British/American CSR reports, enhance their corporate narration in the international communities, and thus reinforce communication with the general public by appropriately expressing and accurately translating transitivity processes.Plain Language SummaryThis paper describes the transitivity attributes of English-medium Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) reports by Chinese and British/American corporations, and the transitivity variances between industries by Chinese corporations. It discovers that the transitivity frequencies in the British/American CSR reports are significantly higher than those in the Chinese counterparts, and the relational process dominates in the sub-corpora under investigation. Cross-industrial analysis across Chinese corporations shows that the mechanical manufacturing industry and the iron & steel enterprises share similar transitivity code, but they are distinctively different from the energy enterprises. It is concluded that linguistic and cultural differences, translation strategies, moves in the CSR reports and etc. together contribute to the transitivity conformities and peculiarities in different cultural backgrounds. By showing the cultural meaning of transitivity and its application variances in CSR reports in guiding communicative conduct, this paper illustrates how transitivity codes might be used to present and explain communicative conducts. This paper might help writers/translators of CSR reports in China better understand lexical and functional conformities and peculiarities reflected in Chinese and British/American CSR reports, enhance their corporate narration in the international communities, and thus reinforce communication with the general public by appropriately expressing and accurately translating transitivity processes. Future work on the transitivity processes of business reports can make exploration into the Chinese-medium CSR reports by Chinese corporations, and then the degree to which transitivity process is influenced by translation strategies or L1 could be evaluated.
social sciences, interdisciplinary