Abstract:Declining levels of turnout and growing distrust in political elites are often seen as symptoms of a crisis of representative democracy. Various proposals of reform have been made to reinvigorate representation and political participation. This paper focuses on one aspect of that debate: finding an alternative to FPTP, which is the electoral rule most frequently used in single-member districts, but which is criticized, among others, for allowing only a limited expression of voters' preferences. Many alternative rules are in use or have been suggested, such as Two-Round majority, Instant Runoff, Approval Voting, Majority Judgement, or Range Voting. The literature on these decision rules has concentrated on their formal properties. Yet, we know surprisingly little about how frequently these rules would lead to different outcomes in normal electoral settings. This paper improves our understanding of these rules by examining their mechanical effects. We start from data on voters' party utilities from "real-world" settings, based on CSES data. This allows simulating and comparing the outcomes of different electoral rules under a variety of distributions of voters' party preferences. We then analyze how frequently they lead to different outcomes and identify the contextual characteristics that explain these differences. For the latter question, we focus on a number of party system or electorate's characteristics, which have been highlighted in debates on challenges to representation (such as ideological polarization, party system fragmentation, or affective polarization).

Rational voting behaviour accounting for heterogeneous ballots in British elections

Identifying Brexit voting patterns in the British house of commons: an analysis based on Bayesian mixture models with flexible concomitant covariate effects

Statistical models of ballot truncation in ranked choice elections

Analysing vote-choice in a multinational state: national identity and territorial differentiation in the 2016 Brexit vote

A mixture of experts model for rank data with applications in election studies

Assessing uncertainty of voter transitions estimated from aggregated data. Application to the 2017 French presidential election

Modeling Peoples Voting Behavior with Poll Information

Voter demographics and socio-economic factors in kinetic models for opinion formation

A Unified Evaluation of Two-Candidate Ballot-Polling Election Auditing Methods

Modeling Voters in Multi-Winner Approval Voting

Inferring Population Preferences via Mixtures of Spatial Voting Models

Rationalizing systematic discrepancies between election outcomes and opinion polls

Do voters choose rationally, irrationally or at random? Data and theory for proportional elections

Modeling undecided voters to forecast elections: From bandwagon behavior and the spiral of silence perspective

Explaining Differences in Voting Patterns Across Voting Domains Using Hierarchical Bayesian Models

Alternatives to plurality rule for single-winner elections: When do they make a difference?

Universality in voting behavior: an empirical analysis

Probabilistic Models of Profiles for Voting by Evaluation

New fairness criteria for truncated ballots in multi-winner ranked-choice elections

KOALA: A new paradigm for election coverage

Define and Explain the Concept of Rationality in the Context of Voting and Political Behavior