Abstract:Public disclosure about effectiveness of internal control systems is subject to much controversy in Canada, resulting in Canadian disclosures being made in Management Discussion and Analysis (MD&A). These disclosures are provided to investors without a definition of the weaknesses to be reported, without implementation effectiveness testing, no direct management certification and no external audit of such disclosures. Though the cost of such SOX North disclosures are lower than in the U.S. setting, the credibility of these disclosures is far from assured, posing an important empirical issue for regulators interested in the cost versus benefit trade-off of various disclosure regimes. We use OLS regression and path analysis embedded in a structural model to examine the association between the strength of internal control and accrual quality in order to infer whether these disclosures are credible. The OLS regression finding of an overall negative net effect of internal control weaknesses on accrual quality is refined by recursive path analysis which shows that this overall negative effect is composed of a large negative direct effect of weaknesses on accrual quality and a smaller offsetting positive indirect effect of weaknesses on accrual quality via increased audit effort. The modest substitution effect implies that auditors cannot fully compensate for poor internal control by increased substantive work, which is per se evidence justifying some form of internal control disclosures for investors. Overall, our results suggest that lower cost SOX North disclosures are credible. This informs the cost-benefit debate facing regulators around the globe seeking alternatives to the costly U.S. model of internal control reporting. JEL Classifications: G38, M41, M42

Internal Control Quality: The Role of Auditor-Provided Tax Services

Internal Control Deficiencies in Tax Reporting: A Detailed View

External Auditor Responses to Tax Risk

Tax Avoidance and the Implications of Weak Internal Controls

Do SOX 404 Control Audits and Management Assessments Improve Overall Internal Control System Quality

The Effect of SOX Internal Control Deficiencies and Their Remediation on Accrual Quality

Audit Committees and Internal Control Quality: Evidence from Nonprofit Hospitals Subject to the Single Audit Act

Internal Control Quality: The Role of Critical Audit Matters Reporting

Direct and Indirect Effects of Internal Control Weaknesses on Accrual Quality: Evidence from A Unique Canadian Regulatory Setting

PCAOB Inspections, Knowledge Diffusion, and Corporate Tax Planning Effectiveness

The Association between Auditor Provided Tax Planning and Tax Compliance Services and Tax Avoidance and Tax Risk

Business Strategy, Internal Control over Financial Reporting, and Audit Reporting Quality

Disclosure of tax‐related critical audit matters and tax‐related outcomes

Information Technology Capability, Internal Control Effectiveness, and Audit Fees and Delays

Audit Committee Quality and Internal Control: An Empirical Analysis

Does Audit Committee Accounting Expertise Help to Promote Audit Quality? Evidence from Auditor Reporting of Internal Control Weaknesses

Perceived tax audit aggressiveness, tax control frameworks and tax planning: an empirical analysis

Internal control deficiencies and the issuance of going concern opinions

Does audit regulation improve corporate decision making? Evidence from the disclosure of tax‐related key audit matters

The importance of the internal information environment for tax avoidance