Abstract:Abstract Balance theory explains how network structural configurations relate to tension in social systems, which are commonly modeled as static undirected signed graphs. We expand this modeling approach by incorporating directionality of edges and considering three levels of analysis for balance assessment: triads, subgroups, and the whole network. For triad-level balance, we develop a new measure by utilizing semicycles that satisfy the condition of transitivity. For subgroup-level balance, we propose measures of cohesiveness (intra-group solidarity) and divisiveness (inter-group antagonism) to capture balance within and among subgroups. For network-level balance, we re-purpose the normalized line index to incorporate directionality and assess balance based on the proportion of edges whose position suits balance. Through comprehensive computational analyses, we quantify, analyze, and compare patterns of social structure in triads, subgroups, and the whole network across a range of social settings. We then apply our multilevel framework to examine balance in temporal and multilayer networks to demonstrates the generalizability of our approach. In most cases, we find relatively high balance across the three levels; providing another confirmation of balance theory. We also deliver empirical evidence for the argument that balance at different levels is not the same social phenomenon measured at different scales, but represents different properties (triadic balance, internal cohesion and external division of subgroups, and overall network polarization), and should therefore be evaluated independently from one another. We propose a comprehensive yet parsimonious approach to address this need.

Community detectability and structural balance dynamics in signed networks

Community detection based on structural balance in signed networks

Spreading and Structural Balance on Signed Networks

Population-Level Balance in Signed Networks

Active influence in dynamical models of structural balance in social networks

Spectral Analysis Of K-Balanced Signed Graphs

Polarization and multiscale structural balance in signed networks

Applications of Structural Balance in Signed Social Networks

Assessing frustration in real-world signed networks: a statistical theory of balance

Testing structural balance theories in heterogeneous signed networks

The energy landscape of social balance

Structural Balance and Random Walks on Complex Networks with Complex Weights

Disagreement and Antagonism in Signed Networks: A Survey

Local sign stability and its implications for spectra of sparse random graphs and stability of ecosystems

Examining spectral space of complex networks with positive and negative links.

Spectral signatures of structural change in financial networks

On Modularity of Social Network Communities: the Spectral Characterization

Multilevel structural evaluation of signed directed social networks based on balance theory

Structural Balance in Real-World Social Networks: Incorporating Direction and Transitivity in Measuring Partial Balance