Spectral signatures of structural change in financial networks

Valentina Macchiati,Emiliano Marchese,Piero Mazzarisi,Diego Garlaschelli,Tiziano Squartini
2024-09-05
Abstract:The level of systemic risk in economic and financial systems is strongly determined by the structure of the underlying networks of interdependent entities that can propagate shocks and stresses. Since changes in network structure imply changes in risk levels, it is important to identify structural transitions potentially leading to system-wide crises. Methods have been proposed to assess whether a real-world network is in a (quasi-)stationary state by checking the consistency of its structural evolution with appropriate maximum-entropy ensembles of graphs. While previous analyses of this kind have focused on dyadic and triadic motifs, hence disregarding higher-order structures, here we consider closed walks of any length. Specifically, we study the ensemble properties of the spectral radius of random graph models calibrated on real-world evolving networks. Our approach is shown to work remarkably well for directed networks, both binary and weighted. As illustrative examples, we consider the Electronic Market for Interbank Deposit (e-MID), the Dutch Interbank Network (DIN) and the International Trade Network (ITN) in their evolution across the 2008 crisis. By monitoring the deviation of the spectral radius from its ensemble expectation, we find that the ITN remains in a (quasi-)equilibrium state throughout the period considered, while both the DIN and e-MID exhibit a clear out-of-equilibrium behaviour. The spectral deviation therefore captures ongoing topological changes, extending over all length scales, to provide a compact proxy of the resilience of economic and financial networks.
Physics and Society,Risk Management
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem this paper attempts to address is how structural changes in economic and financial networks affect systemic risk. Specifically, the authors propose a method to detect whether these networks are in a (quasi-)steady state and capture changes in network topology by monitoring deviations of the network's spectral radius from its expected value. This method can serve as a compact proxy for measuring the resilience of economic and financial networks. The paper focuses on: 1. **(Quasi-)Steady State Detection**: Investigating whether actual economic and financial networks can be considered typical members of a set of (quasi-)steady state graphs. 2. **Early Warning Signals**: Extending the study of early warning signals by considering closed paths of arbitrary length to identify impending crises. 3. **Application of Spectral Radius**: Using the spectral radius and its deviation from a benchmark model to detect changes in network structure. Through this method, the authors demonstrate the behavioral differences of various networks during the 2008 financial crisis. In particular, the International Trade Network (ITN) maintained a (quasi-)steady state throughout the study period, while the Dutch Interbank Network (DIN) and the electronic interbank market (e-MID) exhibited significant non-equilibrium behavior.