An experimental investigation of surfactant structure–property relationship for foam mobility control in thermal EOR processes

Thu Nguyen,Renke Rommerskirchen,Jorge Fernandez,Quoc P. Nguyen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12517-022-09533-1

2022-01-24

Arabian Journal of Geosciences

Abstract:The injection of steam into a viscous oil reservoir as an enhanced oil recovery method is a mature technology. However, due to steam’s high mobility, this process can suffer from gravity override and loss to thief zones. Steam foam has been used successfully since the 1970s to improve the sweep efficiency of steam processes by temporarily increasing the apparent viscosity of steam. One of the important issues in steam foam design that will be addressed in the following study is that no commercially available cost-effective surfactants existed that would allow the creation of steam foam at elevated temperatures (above 200 °C). While alpha olefin sulfonates have been commonly used as a foaming agent, the thermal stability of this surfactant changes with temperature. In this study, a new class of alkyl propoxy ethoxy ether carboxylate (alkyl PO EO ECA) surfactants were evaluated. Surfactant solutions at 1 wt.% were aged at up to 250 °C. The degradation of the surfactants was quantified based on high-performance liquid chromatography. The foaming performance of the surfactants was evaluated at varied temperatures from 100 to 250 °C in a high-pressure visual cell. Sandpack flooding experiments were performed to evaluate the ability of surfactants to increase foam viscosity. The results showed that alkyl PO EO ECA surfactants exhibit excellent chemical stability at up to 250 °C. However, the stability of these surfactants is dependent on the hydrophobic structure as well as the numbers of PO and EO units. An increase in the hydrophobic chain length up to C17 improved initial bulk foam volume, but not foam stability. Having higher degrees of ethoxylations with long and/or highly branched hydrophobes reduces the degradation of the surfactant at high temperature. The addition of PO into the surfactant molecular structure significantly improves the chemical stability of the surfactant. The most promising ECA structure demonstrated to be excellent foaming agents that were able to generate stable foam at 250 °C, and to increase foam viscosity by three orders of magnitude at 250 °C in sandpacks. In the presence of bitumen, these surfactants were able to increase foam viscosity by two orders of magnitude. This increase in the apparent viscosity would be sufficient to overcome the steam override and channeling during steam injection. The findings of this study have advanced our understanding of the structure–property relationships that can be used to optimize surfactants as foaming agents for thermal EOR processes at up to 250 °C.

geosciences, multidisciplinary