The Sun Also Rises': Hemingway and the Art of Repetition

E. Miller Budick

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3138/utq.56.2.319

1987-01-01

University of Toronto Quarterly

Abstract:For the larger part of Hemingway's The Sun Also Rises, Jake's autobiographical narrative consists of a psychological fantasy in which neurosis has overtaken literature and the story has resisted consolidation into a work of art. In Hemingway's narrative structure, Jake Barnes and Robert Cohn, along with the stories which they tell or which are told about them, enact the book's major themes, one of which is the failure of certain kinds of story-telling to achieve dramatic objectivity and literary power. In Jake's narrative seen in itself, however, characters and events demonstrate his unconscious, uncontrolled projections and repressions. Cohn, for example, can be understood in Jake's story as representing one such unintentional projection in which Jake identifies with qualities he himself does not possess—himself as boxing champion, lady's man, successful writer—and in which he reveals the feelings of emotional inadequacy, effeminacy, and impotence which on a conscious level he represses. This disjunction between authorial and narrative texts is, I believe, an explicit concern of the book. Hemingway writes and rewrites Jake's autobiography in order to demonstrate the difference between the mindless and uncritical repetitions of life and literature, which conceal and distort, and the revisionary texts which interpretatively reproduce the repeating patterns of experience and, in so doing, create the possibility for psychological health and purposeful art.