Abstract:This study examines issues of algorithmic fairness in the context of systems that inform tax audit selection by the United States Internal Revenue Service (IRS). While the field of algorithmic fairness has developed primarily around notions of treating like individuals alike, we instead explore the concept of vertical equity -- appropriately accounting for relevant differences across individuals -- which is a central component of fairness in many public policy settings. Applied to the design of the U.S. individual income tax system, vertical equity relates to the fair allocation of tax and enforcement burdens across taxpayers of different income levels. Through a unique collaboration with the Treasury Department and IRS, we use access to anonymized individual taxpayer microdata, risk-selected audits, and random audits from 2010-14 to study vertical equity in tax administration. In particular, we assess how the use of modern machine learning methods for selecting audits may affect vertical equity. First, we show how the use of more flexible machine learning (classification) methods -- as opposed to simpler models -- shifts audit burdens from high to middle-income taxpayers. Second, we show that while existing algorithmic fairness techniques can mitigate some disparities across income, they can incur a steep cost to performance. Third, we show that the choice of whether to treat risk of underreporting as a classification or regression problem is highly consequential. Moving from classification to regression models to predict underreporting shifts audit burden substantially toward high income individuals, while increasing revenue. Last, we explore the role of differential audit cost in shaping the audit distribution. We show that a narrow focus on return-on-investment can undermine vertical equity. Our results have implications for the design of algorithmic tools across the public sector.

Filling the Tax Gap via Programmable Money

Making Tax Smart: Feasibility of Distributed Ledger Technology for building tax compliance functionality to Central Bank Digital Currency

Catch Me If You Can: Combatting Fraud in Artificial Currency Based Government Benefits Programs

Use of two Public Distributed Ledgers to track the money of an economy

On the Use of Computer Programs as Money

A Framework for Programmability in Digital Currency

A blockchain-based certifiable anonymous E-taxing protocol.

zkTax: A pragmatic way to support zero-knowledge tax disclosures

Algorithmic Fairness and Vertical Equity: Income Fairness with IRS Tax Audit Models

Data-driven auditing of business and self-employment earnings

Tax Declaration Scheme Using Blockchain Confidential Transactions

Dynamic effects of tax audits and the role of intentions

Citizen Tax Juries: Democratizing Tax Enforcement after the Panama Papers

Effective Taxation System by Blockchain Technology

You don't need an invoice, do you? An online experiment on collaborative tax evasion

Measuring and Mitigating Racial Disparities in Tax Audits

Nudges, Boosts, and Sludge: Using New Behavioral Approaches to Improve Tax Compliance

Metamorphic Testing and Debugging of Tax Preparation Software

A Theory of the Tax Avoidance (Tax Planning) Continuum

Using deep Q-learning to understand the tax evasion behavior of risk-averse firms

Microscopic models for the study of taxpayer audit effects