Abstract:Abstract In literature, 3D-3D superimposition has been widely recognized as a valid method for personal identification. However, very little information is available about possible variability due to differences in protocols of registration of 3D models and calculation of RMS (root mean square) point-to-point distance. Frontal sinuses from 50 CT scans were segmented twice through the ITK-SNAP software and grouped in two samples (1 and 2). Maximum breadth, height and volume were measured. 3D models belonging to the same subject were then superimposed one on each other in 50 matches. In addition, superimposition of 50 random mismatches was performed. For each superimposition, the procedure was repeated four times choosing different reference models both for registration and calculation of RMS. Differences in RMS value among protocols of registration and RMS calculation were assessed through paired Student’s t -test ( p < 0.05). Possible correlations between differences in RMS among groups and differences in frontal sinus size between the superimposed models were analysed through calculation of Pearson’s correlation coefficient ( p < 0.05). Results showed that RMS calculation did not yield significant differences according to which 3D model is used as reference; on the other hand, RMS values from registration procedure significantly differ according to which model is chosen as reference, but only in the mismatch group ( p < 0.001). Differences in RMS value according to RMS calculation are dependent upon all the three measurements, whereas differences according to registration protocols were significantly related only with the breadth of frontal sinuses but only in mismatches ( p < 0.001). In no case, superimpositions of RMS values were found between matches and mismatches. This article for the first time proves that the protocol of registration and calculation of RMS significantly influences the results of 3D-3D superimposition only in case of mismatches.

Personal identification using frontal sinus coding methods: The effect of mixed image modality comparisons

Analysis of Frontal Sinuses for Personal Identification in a Chinese Sample Using a New Code Number

Human identification: an investigation of 3D models of paranasal sinuses to establish a biological profile on a modern UK population

Identification score for robust and secure identification using ante- and post-mortem skull CT scans

Computer-aided superimposition of the frontal sinus via 3D reconstruction for comparative forensic identification

Pitfalls of Computed Tomography 3D Reconstruction Models in Cranial Nonmetric Analysis*

The Effects of Cranial Orientation on Forensic Frontal Sinus Identification as Assessed by Outline Analyses

Assessment of Anatomical Uniqueness of Maxillary Sinuses through 3D-3D Superimposition: An Additional Help to Personal Identification

Research Progress on Individual Identification by Frontal Sinus Imaging.

A post-processing technique for cranial CT image identification.

Efficacy of Frontal Sinus as a Reliable Tool for Sex Differentiation - A Cross-Sectional Study

Forensic Identification from Three-Dimensional Sphenoid Sinus Images Using the Iterative Closest Point Algorithm

Human identification through forensic skeletal analysis: three case reviews

A Novel Algorithm for Forensic Identification Using Geometric Cranial Patterns in Digital Lateral Cephalometric Radiographs in Forensic Dentistry

Validating the use of clinical MSCT scans for cranial nonmetric sex estimation in a contemporary Indonesian population

The Doppelgänger Effect? A comparative study of forensic facial depiction methods

Does the choice of the reference model affect the results of 3D-3D superimposition procedure? A comparison of different protocols for personal identification

Study on the identification limits of craniofacial superimposition

Technical Note: Individuals identified by radiographic comparison: A sample of demographics and the region of body used for identification in Clark County, Nevada, USA (2017–2020)

Convolutional mesh autoencoders for the 3-dimensional identification of FGFR-related craniosynostosis

Sex estimation using paranasal sinus discriminant analysis: a new approach via cone beam computerized tomography volume analysis