Abstract:Previous research has shown that as the level of background noise increases, auditory word recognition performance drops off more rapidly for bilinguals than monolinguals. This disproportionate bilingual deficit has often been attributed to a presumed increase in cross-language activation in noise, although no studies have specifically tested for such an increase. We propose two distinct mechanisms by which background noise could cause an increase in cross-language activation: a phonetically based account and an executive function-based account. We explore the evidence for the phonetically based account by comparing cognate facilitation effects for three groups of native English listeners (monolinguals, late (L2) learners of Spanish, and heritage Spanish speakers) and four noise conditions (no noise, speech-shaped noise, English two-talker babble, and Spanish two-talker babble) during an auditory lexical decision task in English. By examining word recognition in the dominant language, the role of language control mechanisms is minimized, and by examining three different types of competing noise, the role of energetic vs. informational masking can be assessed. Contrary to predictions, we find no evidence that background noise modulates cross-language activation; cognate facilitation is constant across the four noise conditions. Instead, several indices of word recognition performance are found to correlate with aspects of linguistic experience: (1) The magnitude of the cognate facilitation effect is correlated with heritage listeners' self-ratings of Spanish proficiency; (2) Overall noise deficits are marginally larger for heritage listeners with lower English vocabulary scores; (3) Heritage listeners' Spanish self-ratings predict their magnitude of informational masking; (4) For all bilinguals, the degree of masking incurred in both English and Spanish two-talker babble is correlated with self-reported daily exposure to Spanish; and (5) The degree of masking incurred by Spanish babble is correlated with Spanish vocabulary knowledge. The results enrich our understanding of auditory word recognition in heritage speakers in particular and provide evidence that informational masking is most subject to modulation due to variation in linguistic experience. It remains to be seen whether cross-language activation is modulated by noise when the target language is the less dominant one.

Xie, Liu, & Jaeger (2020). Cross-talker generalization during foreign-accented speech perception

Cross-talker generalization in the perception of nonnative speech: A large-scale replication.

Foreign language talker identification does not generalize to new talkers

The interacting effects of talker, contrast, and listener variability in cross-language speech perception

The Effect of Intensified Language Exposure on Accommodating Talker Variability.

Interaction of long-term acoustic experience and local context information on the perceptual accommodation of talker variability

Transfer of statistical learning from passive speech perception to speech production

Going Beyond Rote Auditory Learning: Neural Patterns of Generalized Auditory Learning

Compensation for coarticulation despite a midway speaker change: Reassessing effects and implications

EXPRESS: Speaker Variability, But Not Bilingualism, Influences Cross-Situational Word Learning

Perceptual Benefits of Linguistic Diversity and Language Background: Evidence from Auditory Free Classification of English Dialect Accents and Asian-Accented English

Does race impact speech perception? An account of accented speech in two different multilingual locales

On improving the perception of foreign-accented speech

Replicability of neural responses to speech accent is driven by study design and analytical parameters

Hierarchical contributions of linguistic knowledge to talker identification: Phonological versus lexical familiarity

Language-general versus language-specific processes in bilingual voice learning

When Jack isn't Jacques: Simultaneous opposite language-specific speech perceptual learning in French-English bilinguals

Comparative Acoustic Analyses of L2 English: The Search for Systematic Variation

How many voices did you hear? Natural variability disrupts identity perception from unfamiliar voices

Multiple talker processing in autistic adult listeners

Modulation of Cross-Language Activation During Bilingual Auditory Word Recognition: Effects of Language Experience but Not Competing Background Noise