An Ethical Criticism of Paid News

D. Ming-ying

Abstract:The phenomenon of paid news is found in news broadcasting.It finds expressions in various forms.This essay holds that the phenomenon is inconsistent with the law and morality.In order to stop the phenomenon,we must resort to the two means,that is,the law and morality.

Sociology,Philosophy,Law

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Concept of Paid News in Indian Print Media

P. Thomas,Lakshmi L Lund

DOI: https://doi.org/10.15655/MW/2012/V3I1/53616

2012-01-01

Media Watch

Abstract:Print media in India have been witnessing a rapid boom during the last two decades. On the contrary developed nations like the United State of America and some European countries have recorded a steep fall both in newspaper readership and growth. The growth of newspapers in India is a positive sign of democracy. However, in recent past there are some instances of unfair and unethical means practised by certain sections of Indian media that undermine the public service value of journalism. The phenomena of paid news have acquired serious dimensions in the media world. Today, it goes beyond the corruption of the individual journalist and media company and has become pervasive, structured and highly organized. In this process it is undermining the Indian democratic value. The paper brings to light how candidate Ashok Chavan made advantageous use of the print media (in Indian languages and print) during the Maharashtra state elections in 2009. A lot of news stories and editorials, that were paid for were published with and without bylines in dailies. No mention of the words ‘advt’, 'paid for', ‘advertorial’ was made on the same. Paid news is not active during elections per se. Paid news has also taken the form of 'private treaty' where the media company enters into a contract with the corporate house and the company's equity shares are exchanged for advertising contracts. The authors have made an attempt to keep the trouble of paid news in the Indian print media under control, and indicated some remedial measures.

Sociology,Political Science
Analysis of the Criminal Liability of the Payoff Journalism

Tang-fa CHEN

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-3571.2015.06.013

2015-01-01

Abstract:The payoff journalism claimed for criminal liabilities when damaging to the reputation of the business and products should meet the following requirements :w hether the media opinion is a commercial tool for the unfair competition ;w hether the result of damage to the reputation is out of the direct intent ;whether the responsibility of infringement is consistent with the penalty .The payoff journalist can consti‐tute the crime of "extortion" or "bribery".Although the judicial practice is alternative of extortion and bribery ,the application cases of bribery have been increased ,w hich indicate the legal authorities'determi‐nation to fight the payoff journalism .The essential element of the bribery crime is seeking benefits for oth‐ers rather than extorting bribes initiatively .Therefore it is hard to make the applicable law for the trading behaviors behind the positive reports which can be regarded as the non‐extorting bribery crime .
On the Examination of the Truth of the News Informings

Li Ming

2008-01-01

Abstract:The paper reviewes the origin of news informants,analyzes the initiative and passive cause of the inconsistence with the facts of news informings,and suggests to examine the truth of what the news informants offered through three aspects:filtration,proof and regulation.
A New Exploration of Journalism: Strengthen the Connection with Its Audience

Wu Fei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02529203.2021.1924468

2021-01-01

Social Sciences in China

Abstract:Traditional media are facing a crisis of declining trust, public disengagement, and declining revenue. More and more people are avoiding and rejecting traditional news because of its depressing effect on their feelings. The constructive journalism movement seeks to correct the negative bias of traditional journalism, strengthen the connection between the media industry and its audience, and reestablish the authority and legitimacy of journalism. This new model of journalism can give hope to a life that is "not-yet" and encourage people to move forward to solve social problems with a positive mindset. In the current era of public communications, constructive journalism offers a new option for people to rethink the many possibilities for journalists, the news communication system, and the journalism industry and thus shape their own social roles and positioning.
Media Corruption: A Chinese Characteristic

Ren Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-012-1464-6

IF: 6.331

2012-01-01

Journal of Business Ethics

Abstract:Misbehaviour and malpractices of Chinese journalists in recent years have brought media corruption under the spotlight. The lack of professionalism and scarcity of fully established ethics in media organisations have made the case worse. However, while Chinese media and academics concentrate narrowly on paid-for news or gag fee by prompting the enforcement of disciplinary restraints and ‘thought education’, this hot issue has been largely ignored by western scholars and has only been occasionally reported by some western media. Based mainly on prominent cases and document studies, this article classifies three major types of media corruption in the Chinese context: (1) individual red-envelope taking, (2) institutional profit seeking and (3) personal businesses benefiting from the identity of a reporter. It then explores two major endogenous causes of media corruption: media’s unique role in China’s political power structure and their monopoly in information collection and delivery. Two current countermeasures undertaken against this phenomenon in China are finally analysed.
Ethical Risk Perception of Freebies and Effects on Journalists' Ethical Reasoning

Ven-hwei Lo,Ran Wei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17544750701861889

IF: 3.698

2008-01-01

Chinese Journal of Communication

Abstract:Accepting freebies and the consequence of doing so is a long‐standing ethical issue in journalism. Critics argue that freebies corrupt journalists and undercut the integrity of journalism. Working journalists tend to agree. Accepting freebies, however, is widespread in many countries. Why is there such an attitude‐behavior gap? Surveying 771 journalists in Taiwan, we explored the gap from the framework of optimistic bias regarding risk perceptions and risk‐taking behavior. Results reveal that most journalists thought freebies were unacceptable, but they perceived their peers as more vulnerable to the freebies‐accepting situation than themselves. The less vulnerable to such situations those journalists felt, the more tolerant they were toward freebies and the more likely they were to accept them.
Qualitative Discussior on Reporter Bribery and Extortion

MENG Qing-hua,LI Jia-rui

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-2603.2010.06.012

2010-01-01

Abstract:The press coverage in official interviews or features,should be classified as "state-owned business units engaged in official business",so a reporter could be the main accepting bribes.In judicial practice,there are many cases bribes journalists convicted and sentenced by extortion.When a "national staff" in the press,in the performance of their duties in the unit to be critical reports obtained property,more elements of the crime of bribery;but posing as journalists and bribes,then can be defined as extortion and blackmail."Non-state institutions" and "corporate" in the press bribery,extortion,shall constitute the "non-national staff of accepting bribes."
Ethical Orientation and Judgments of Chinese Press Journalists in Times of Change

Francis Lee,Di Cui,Zhian Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/23736992.2015.1050558

2015-01-01

Journal of Media Ethics

Abstract:Against the background of media and social transformation, this study examines Chinese press journalists' ethical orientation and tolerance for ethically controversial practices. The former captures journalists' theoretical conception of ethics along a consequentialist versus absolutist spectrum; the latter speaks to journalists' ethical judgment in relation to concrete practices. Analysis of a survey of press journalists (N = 2,109) found that a substantial minority of the respondents were subscribing to ethical relativism. Different types of controversial reporting practices were tolerated to different extents. Multivariate analysis shows that those working in online newsrooms, those who perceived substantial commercial influences on news work, and those who valued the advocacy role of the press exhibited a stronger relativistic orientation, whereas respondents who valued the information dissemination role of the press exhibited a stronger absolutist orientation. But there are mixed findings regarding the impact of other predictors, which hint at the complexities of the evolution of journalism ethics in China.
Legal Regulations on Critical Views

CHEN Tangfa

2010-01-01

Journal of International Communication

Abstract:Media's critical views should make the vehement condemn according with fact's attribute and property and be expressed by submitting to law foundation.Quotation from experts should pay attention to balancing the different and conflict opinions.When negative views are expressed,incorrect suspecting,judging and concluding about case statement should be avoided.
A Survey on Legal Consciousness and Judicial Circumstances of Critical Reports

Tang-fa CHEN

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-260X.2009.03.025

2009-01-01

Abstract:As regards the debunking and accusatory attitude as manifest in coverage of critical reports,judges tend to approach and interpret law in more rational and appropriate terms than do journalists who prefer emotional and subjective expression.Media people go by the professional criterion that "constitutive components of news are basically true",when it comes to media objectivity.Judges,however,are inclined to priotize strict objectivity when exposed to media and confronting actual constraints that work against ideal objectivity.
On the Restriction of Press Ethic on Press Activities

Ding Boquan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1003-8671.2007.05.042

2007-01-01

Abstract:Press ethic is both the norms with which the press discipline themsevles according to characteristics of press activities and the public restrictions on the press in press activities. Journalists' press ethic offences of is related to the unbalance in their relationips with the audience, the persons concerned and rivals. Therefore, press ethic offences must be strictly avoided in an effort to internalize press ethic into journalists' qualities, to specialize related principle norms according to requirements for press activities, and to perform an effective media correction mechanism.
Ethical Literary Criticism: Its Fundaments and Terms

Nie Zhenzhao

2010-01-01

Abstract:Ethical literary criticism is a research method to read, analyze and interpret literary works, to study literary authors and literary problems from perspective of ethics. The basic thought of this method is that literature is the art of ethics in nature as it is the special expressions of ethical ideas and moral life in a particular historical period. Literature is not art of languages but of text consisting of characters. It is not ideology or aesthetic ideology, but material form existing by literal text. Teaching or instruction is the essential attribute and first function of literature, but aesthetic appreciation is the second which serves the first. By use of terms such as ethics, incest, ethical taboo, ethical chaos, ethical consciousness, ethical situation, ethical identity, ethical choice, etc., the ethical literary criticism explains and comments the different life with its moral features from ethical perspective.
Promotion and Resistance: The Difficulty and Resolution of Establishing News Paywall in China

Ruiyang Cheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54097/hbem.v19i.11886

2023-11-02

Abstract:The news paywall, an access mechanism for news providers to implement pay-per-read for online news and information content originated in the U.S. news industry, is seen as an essential part of the news industry’s profitability model in the Internet era, comparable in importance to advertising. However, the development of the mechanism in the Chinese news market has yet to be satisfactory, and its promotion has been repeatedly blocked. Few scholars have comprehensively evaluated the differences in developing and promoting the new paywall in Chinese news market from political, economic, and cultural aspects. Hence, the study adopts a case study method to analyze the difficulties in developing and promoting the news paywall system in China in terms of the composition and function of the news industry, and the public's understanding and perception of the news industry, and the news industry's adopting a pay-for-content strategy. Eventually, the paper aims to provide corresponding solutions by incorporating the U.S. paywall development experience. This study argues that balancing the development of news media's functions of guiding public opinion and providing professional information services, activating the social attributes of paywalls, and clarifying charging strategy can help with the development and popularization of the news paywall in China's news market.
The Scandal of News of the World and Retrospect on Western Idea of Freedom of Press

Tong Bing

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-8263.2012.03.017

2012-01-01

Abstract:This article discusses the origin and causality of the phone hacking scandal of U.K tabloid newspaper News of the World,its social and institutional corruption background.Critical review and analysis on the parent company of News of the World,the News Group Newspapers and its real owner Rupert Murdoch were also the main topic of this article.The author argues the used creed of Western idea of freedom of press have been distorted by market competition and moral degeneration in this scandal,which alarm all news professionals should take serious attitude on social responsibility and work ethics.Besides,this article also reviews the current behaviors of Chinese media.
News Reports on Corruption Scandals in China:Production Mechanism and Its Operation

Dongxiao Li

2010-01-01

Abstract:Corruption scandals refer to the publicized information concerning the conducts of government officials or authorities that go against the law,government regulations,social ethics or the public opinion.A probe into the production mechanism of news reports on such scandals may help us understand how various social powers affect the revealing of the scandals via their influences on the mass media.In China,political factors have been a decisive force in the production of news reports on corruption scandals.The mass media,influenced by both the market and the government policy towards media,are then in a dilemma: on the one hand,they are strongly motivated to reveal corruption scandals as much,and as completely,as possible;on the other,restricted by the press censorship and other implicit rules,they have to be in consistency with the government's policies towards the news reports on such scandals.The civil society,not yet full-fledged in China,fails to offer a favorable public-opinion arena to the production of news reports on such scandals.As a result,the Internet is becoming a new force that complements the traditional mass media in this regard.
Ethical Literary Criticism in China

NIE Zhen-zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-2338.2010.05.006

2011-01-01

Abstract:Ethical literary criticism has been a methodology in China since 2004,as at that year two conferences in that field were held respectively in Nanchang and Yichang and then comes the highly-cited paper "Ethical Approach to Literary Studies: A New Perspective." Compared with ethic criticism in west countries,ethical literary criticism in China has its own features: it changes the literary ethics into ethical literary criticism as a mean efficiently to solve practical literary questions,uses the concept of ethical literary criticism rather than ethical criticism to construct its own discourse,and discusses the basic theoretical questions by case studies.It is those features that make it different from ethical criticism in the west,as well as moral criticism in China.
How to Keep the Balance between the Professional Ethics and the Social Morality

SHEN Nan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-4193.2011.02.022

2011-01-01

Abstract:In the reformation of the social economic system,along with the developing market economy construction,the media oneself is also in the restructuring-transforming from the pure institutions and the party's mouthpiece to the enterprise.But in this process,some journalists,due to a variety of reasons,in the face of concerns people's life safety incident,have lost their professional ethics and social morality and only focus on the "objective news events" news.How to keep balance between the professional ethics and the social morality becomes a big problem of the media practitioners.
On Law Sources and Principles of Restricted Media Coverage

Wen-jun WANG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-2338.2014.06.017

2014-01-01

Abstract:Restricted media coverage is a sensitive topic of the press in China, which is associated with the restriction on the free-dom of the press.However, it is often the case of coverage restriction in accordance with the law in legal states.In fact, restric-tion on media coverage is consistent with the basic principles of the press, such as objectivity, impartiality, balance, and etc. Due to the ignorance and indifference of the restricted media coverage, it has been found in China the violation of laws and rules, as well as insufficient and ineffective management of the relevant administrative departments.In spite of the absence of the specific press law, it is not difficult for us to find abundant legal norms concerning the media coverage restriction.However, it is not an easy job to collect all of these items scattered in different domains and departments.Therefore, to sort out law sources and principles of the restricted media coverage not only helps journalists to realize the importance of law-abiding, thus decreasing the frequency of illegal media coverage, but also assists the relevant administrative departments to get rid of the tradi-tional way of“report on each incident”.In this way, a true administrative mechanism is to be established in order to deal with the violation of the restricted media coverage.
Managing Conflicts of Interest in the Financial Media: Evidence from a Natural Experiment in China☆

Yi Ru,Jian Xue,Qian Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaccpubpol.2024.107261

IF: 3.629

2024-01-01

Journal of Accounting and Public Policy

Abstract:This paper examines the effect of media regulation aimed at curbing the media's conflict of interest on news reporting quality and its capital market consequences. Exploiting the large-scale merger and revocation of local reporter stations of Chinese central media outlets as a shock, we document a significant improvement in news reporting quality following the regulation of reporter stations in the province where the firms are located. Cross-sectional analyses show that the effect is stronger when the reporters are ex ante more susceptible to conflicts of interest (i.e., when covering a less transparent firm or stationed farther away from the headquarters, or when the media has closer business relations with the firm). Additionally, after the regulation, the coverage of the treated media is more effective in exposing and raising regulatory awareness of financial fraud, reducing accounting information manipulation, and enhancing market efficiency, consistent with an improvement in firm information environment when covered by media with greater editorial independence. The paper contributes to the research on media in the capital market, and has important practical implications for the healthy development of media outlets.
Editorial reflections about two cases of academic misconduct

Wei Xue-l

Abstract:Through summarizing two cases of academic misconduct in scholarly publishing,we analyzed the new forms and root causes of such misconduct in the background of the media fusion. We think that the academic misconduct could appear in any part of the academic publishing; therefore,we must pay enough attention to it. Consciously moral requirements to scientific research and institutionalized management of publishing process are still main measures to keep the academic purity and prevent misconduct,and should not be ignored.

Political Science,Education

An Ethical Criticism of Paid News

Concept of Paid News in Indian Print Media

Analysis of the Criminal Liability of the Payoff Journalism

On the Examination of the Truth of the News Informings

A New Exploration of Journalism: Strengthen the Connection with Its Audience

Media Corruption: A Chinese Characteristic

Ethical Risk Perception of Freebies and Effects on Journalists' Ethical Reasoning

Qualitative Discussior on Reporter Bribery and Extortion

Ethical Orientation and Judgments of Chinese Press Journalists in Times of Change

Legal Regulations on Critical Views

A Survey on Legal Consciousness and Judicial Circumstances of Critical Reports

On the Restriction of Press Ethic on Press Activities

Ethical Literary Criticism: Its Fundaments and Terms

Promotion and Resistance: The Difficulty and Resolution of Establishing News Paywall in China

The Scandal of News of the World and Retrospect on Western Idea of Freedom of Press

News Reports on Corruption Scandals in China:Production Mechanism and Its Operation

Ethical Literary Criticism in China

How to Keep the Balance between the Professional Ethics and the Social Morality

On Law Sources and Principles of Restricted Media Coverage

Managing Conflicts of Interest in the Financial Media: Evidence from a Natural Experiment in China☆

Editorial reflections about two cases of academic misconduct