Abstract:Deep shale reservoirs (3500–4500 m) exhibit significantly different stress states than moderately deep shale reservoirs (2000–3500 m). As a result, the brittleness response mechanisms of deep shales are also different. It is urgent to investigate methods to evaluate the brittleness of deep shales to meet the increasingly urgent needs of deep shale gas development. In this paper, the quotient of Young's modulus divided by Poisson's ratio based on triaxial compression tests under in situ stress conditions is taken as SSBV (Static Standard Brittleness Value). A new and pragmatic technique is developed to determine the static brittleness index that considers elastic parameters, the mineral content, and the in situ stress conditions (BIEMS). The coefficient of determination between BIEMS and SSBV reaches 0.555 for experimental data and 0.805 for field data. This coefficient is higher than that of other brittleness indices when compared to SSBV. BIEMS can offer detailed insights into shale brittleness under various conditions, including different mineral compositions, depths, and stress states. This technique can provide a solid data-based foundation for the selection of 'sweet spots' for single-well engineering and the comparison of the brittleness of shale gas production layers in different areas.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: In deeper shale reservoirs (3,500 - 4,500 meters), under higher confining pressure conditions, its brittle response mechanism is significantly different from that of mid - deep shale reservoirs (2,000 - 3,500 meters), which leads to the need for improvement in the brittleness evaluation method for deep shale. In order to meet the increasingly urgent demand for deep shale gas development, the study proposes a new practical technique to quantitatively characterize the brittleness of deep shale by integrating mineral content, elastic parameters and in - situ stress conditions.
Specifically, the main objectives of the paper include:
1. **Propose a new brittleness evaluation index**: Based on the in - situ stress conditions under triaxial compression tests, use the quotient of Young's modulus and Poisson's ratio as the static standard brittleness value (SSBV), and develop a new brittleness index (BIEMS), which comprehensively considers elastic parameters, mineral content and in - situ stress conditions.
2. **Improve the accuracy of brittleness evaluation**: Verified by experimental data and field data, the determination coefficients between the newly proposed brittleness index BIEMS and SSBV reach 0.555 and 0.805 respectively, which are higher than other brittleness indices.
3. **Provide practical application guidance**: This technique can provide a solid data basis for the "sweet spot" selection in single - well engineering and the brittleness comparison of shale gas production layers in different regions.
### Paper background
Deep shale reservoirs (3,500 - 4,500 meters) and mid - deep shale reservoirs (2,000 - 3,500 meters) show significantly different stress states under higher confining pressure conditions, which leads to different brittle response mechanisms in deep shale. Therefore, studying the brittleness evaluation method of deep shale is of great significance for the development of deep shale gas.
### Methods
1. **Triaxial compression test**: Obtain Young's modulus and Poisson's ratio of rocks under specific confining pressure conditions through triaxial compression tests, and then calculate the static standard brittleness value (SSBV).
2. **Mineral composition analysis**: Use X - ray diffraction (XRD) to analyze the mineral composition of shale samples and determine the relative content of various minerals.
3. **Dynamic brittleness index calculation**: Calculate the dynamic brittleness index (DBIEMS) by combining mineral content, elastic parameters and in - situ stress conditions.
### Results and discussion
Through the study of Well Z206 in the Yuqi block in western Chongqing, the results show that:
- The change trend of the dynamic brittleness index (DBIEMS) from bottom to top is from small to large and then to small again. The maximum brittleness index value appears in the L111 layer, generally above 2,400 GPa.
- The change law of mineral composition is consistent with the change trend of the dynamic brittleness index, which is in line with the views of many scholars, that is, the mineral composition and its distribution characteristics are the main factors affecting the mechanical brittleness of shale reservoirs.
- The shale reservoir at the bottom of the Changxing Formation was deposited after an important environmental change node during the Ordovician - Silurian transition period. There are good hydrodynamic deposition conditions and organic matter preservation conditions, and the quartz minerals in this period are mainly bioclastic siliceous, with a high quartz content, forming a good mechanical brittle framework.
### Conclusion
The new technique BIEMS proposed in this paper can more accurately characterize the brittleness of deep shale, providing a scientific basis and practical tool for the development of deep shale gas.