Abstract:Background: Numerous publications on natural resource valuations consider contexts where environmental assets at risk are significant to Indigenous Peoples and their estates. In the last two decades alone, many applied studies have aimed at investigating the 'value' of socio-environmental outcomes from the perspectives of the general populations including Indigenous Peoples. The term 'value' is often invoked in varying contexts ranging from empirical research to Natural Resource Management (NRM) strategies and policies. Underpinning all valuation exercises is a conceptual approach to defining and analyzing value, which is contextual given that different philosophies and worldviews consider nature's 'value' differently. Our objective was to understand value philosophies underpinning diverse NRM 'value' paradigms and to evaluate compatibility with Indigenous Peoples' value attribution. Method: We conducted a systematic search for publications on nature studies from multiple databases using a Boolean strategy. The processes for literature identification and selection are presented in a PRISMA flowchart. The study then critically reviewed and synthesized insights from the literature on the interpretations, conceptualizations, and elicitations of value, particularly in contexts where NRM influences Indigenous estates. Review results: We found that philosophical perspectives define how 'value' is conceptualized and evaluated. Most studies reviewed rested on the economic paradigm grounded in anthropocentric utilitarian value-framing, and limited studies considered a relational value lens that reflects Indigenous Peoples' value attribution for the natural environment. A relational lens sits outside of the usual 'instrumental versus intrinsic' value dichotomy and deems human-nature connections coupled, and worthy in themselves. Discussion: The paper demonstrates the commonalities and inconsistencies across diverse value conceptualizations and describes emerging pluralistic approaches consistent with Indigenous value attribution. A novel framework for understanding and bridging the different conceptual and analytical valuation lenses, particularly on water, is presented ensuring that multiple, complex, and distinct value dimensions are empirically bridged in studies involving Indigenous Peoples.

Sustainability certification: multiple values of nature coexist in value chain transformations toward a common but differentiated responsibility

Editorial overview: theoretical traditions in social values for sustainability

Sustainability and Depoliticisation: Certifications in the Cut-Flower Industry at Lake Naivasha, Kenya

Loving the mess: navigating diversity and conflict in social values for sustainability

Lessons from Local Studies for Global Sustainability

What Is the Value of an Environmental Certification Label in Tourism Industry? Is It Worth the Effort?

Beyond Biodiversity: Eliciting Diverse Values of Urban Green Spaces in Flanders

Diverse values of nature for sustainability

Multi-Stakeholder Initiatives on Sustainability: A Cross-Disciplinary Review and Research Agenda for Business Ethics

Controversy Over Voluntary Environmental Standards: A Socioeconomic Analysis of the Marine Stewardship Council

Vertically Differentiating Environmental Standards: The Case of the Marine Stewardship Council

Six modes of co-production for sustainability

Incorporating diverse values of nature in decision-making—theory and practice

“Norming” and “Conforming”: Integrating Cultural and Institutional Explanations for Sustainability Adoption in Business

Dimensions of sustainable value chains: implications for value chain analysis

Why nature matters: A systematic review of intrinsic, instrumental, and relational values

Nature's value, philosophies, theories, and concepts: a critical review and suggestions for future indigenous research

Valuing plurality: Environmental humanities approaches to ecosystem services and Nature's Contributions to People

Enabling Shared Values for Sustainability Transformation: Empirical Lessons from a Case of Promoting Cross-Group Collaboration in China

Corporate Biodiversity Management through Certifiable Standards

Emerging Perspectives on Diverse Nature-Oriented Sustainability Strategies