Abstract:Abstract. This paper provides a bibliometric review between integration of authoritative and volunteered geographic information for the purpose of cartographic updating of urban mappings. The adopted methodology was through a bibliometric survey of the literature published by Web of Science and Science Direct. The period was evaluated from 2005 to 2020 and the keywords used were: integration of authoritative data, volunteered geographic information, VGI, large scale topographic mapping, Authoritative urban mapping. The number of publications found was small for the topic that deals with this integration, totalizing 14 articles at Web of Science and 23 at Science Direct. 38% of them were published in the International Journal of Geo Information (ISPRS), 16% in the International Journal of Geographical Information Science. 5% were published in the Cartography and Geographic Information Science and the Computer Geosciences respectively. The other 36% is shown in several other journals, approximately 3% each. Regarding the origin of publications, 25% are in Germany (University of Heidelberg), 14% in the UK (New Castle University), 13% in China (Wuhan University), 11% in Canada (Calgary University), and other countries show percentages between 3% and 5%. Among the research, areas are physical geography, remote sensing, computer science, information science, engineering, and public administration. Among themes addressed in the articles, potentials can be pointed out as existence of models which institutions can implement management of information received collaboratively, existence of several methodologies for quality control of this information so that they can be integrated into authoritative data that are called as data conflation. Methodologies for handling big data and semantic interoperability, as well as automation of processes. This data potential is not only on platforms such as OpenStreetMap, but also on data collected through scraping from social networks such as twitter, sites, and others. Among the challenges, there are still somethings to investigate regarding consideration of temporal, historic, political, and economic aspects, as well as the consideration of legal aspects. The integration of this volunteered geographic information is necessary, mainly in cities with economic and cultural difficulties to maintain their mapping up to date, as well as the difficulty of accessing information that allows access to authoritative data.

Characterizing collaborative mapping projects. A methodological framework for analyzing volunteered geographic information and spatial data infrastructure convergence

INTEGRATION OF AUTHORITATIVE AND VOLUNTEERED GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION FOR UPDATING URBAN MAPPING: CHALLENGES AND POTENTIALS

Collection and Integration of Local Knowledge and Experience through a Collective Spatial Analysis

Volunteered Geographic Information (VGI) in Spatial Data Infrastructure (SDI) Continuum

Framework of integration for collaboration and spatial data mining among heterogeneous sources in the web

A Survey of Volunteered Open Geo-Knowledge Bases in the Semantic Web

A web-based geovisualization framework for exploratory analysis of individual VGI contributor's participation characteristics

Recent Developments and Future Trends in Volunteered Geographic Information Research: The Case of OpenStreetMap

Volunteered Geographic Information and Computational Geography: New Perspectives

Convergence, Mining, and Application: A Data Collaboration Framework for Spatial-Gene Research and Practice

Conciliating Perspectives from Mapping Agencies and Web of Data on Successful European SDIs: Toward a European Geographic Knowledge Graph

Geographic Information Systems (GISs) Based on WebGIS Architecture: Bibliometric Analysis of the Current Status and Research Trends

Volunteered geographic information systems: Technological design patterns

dciWebMapper: A Data‐Driven and Coordinated View‐Enabled Interactive Web Mapping Framework for Visualizing and Sensing High‐Dimensional Geospatial (Big) Data

Satellite Image Analysis Using Crowdsourcing Data for Collaborative Mapping: Current and Opportunities

Citizens as sensors: the world of volunteered geography

GIS as a Bridge Across the Digital Divide: Engaging Participatory Methods to Build Capacity in Research Communities

Applications of Volunteered Geographic Information in Surveying Engineering: A First Approach

Geovisual analysis of VGI for understanding people's behaviour in relation to multifaceted context

A Multi-stage Collaborative 3D GIS to Support Public Participation

Updating Authoritative Spatial Data from Timely Sources: A Multiple Representation Approach