Abstract:The efficiency increase that distributed propulsion could deliver for future hybrid-electric aircraft is in line with the urgent demand for higher aerodynamic performances and a lower environmental impact. Several consolidated proprietary tools (not always available) are developed worldwide for distributed propulsion simulation. Therefore, prediction and comparisons of propeller performances, with computational fluid dynamic codes featuring different implementation of solvers, numerical schemes, and turbulence models, is of interest to a wider audience of research end-users. In this framework, the paper presents a cross-comparison study among different CFD solvers, the SU2 Multiphysics Simulation and Design Software, the CIRA proprietary flow solver UZEN, and the commercial ANSYS-FLUENT code, for the simulation of a wing section with a tractor propeller at different flow attitudes. The propeller is modelled as an actuator disk according to the general momentum theory and is accounted for in the flow solvers as a boundary condition, for the momentum and energy equations. In this study, a propeller with a fixed advance ratio J=0.63 is considered, while propeller performances are assumed variable along with the radius. To perform the comparisons among the solvers, an in-house procedure, which provides the input thrust and torque distributions in a unified format among the three solvers, is developed. Steady RANS simulations are performed at Re∞=1.7×106 and M∞=0.11, for the flowfield of an isolated propeller. Successively, a wing section with a fixed forward-mounted propeller configuration with no nacelle, is studied at α=0∘,4∘, and 8∘ angles of attack. The comparisons in terms of the lift coefficient show a good agreement among the three flow solvers both in power-off and power-on conditions. Simulations also evidenced the strong stability preserving property of upwind schemes, applied to propeller simulation at low-Mach number. Some discrepancies in the drag coefficient are observed and related to different levels of numerical diffusion between the three codes, which affects the downstream wake. Differences in flow properties in near disk region are observed and explained considering the different hub implementations.

Aircraft Simulations Using the New CFD Software from ONERA, DLR, and Airbus

Constrained Large-Eddy Simulation and Detached Eddy Simulation of Flow Past a Commercial Aircraft at 14 Degrees Angle of Attack

Unsteady Flow Simulation of a Variable-Sweep Morphing Aircraft Coupled with Flight Control System

Implementation of Immersed Boundaries via Volume Penalization in the Industrial Aeronautical Computational Fluid Dynamics Solver CODA

Sensitivities of Free-Air RANS and DDES Methods on the High-Lift NASA CRM

Numerical Investigations Of The Jaxa High-Lift Configuration Standard Model With Mflow Solver

On the role and challenges of CFD in the aerospace industry

Summary of Data from the Sixth AIAA CFD Drag Prediction Workshop: Case 1 Code Verification

Hypersonic simulations using open-source CFD and DSMC solvers

CFD Simulations of Ship Maneuvering with Direct Propeller and Rudder

Rans-Based CFD Prediction of the Hydrodynamic Coefficients of Darpa Suboff Geometry in Straight-Line and Rotating Arm Manoeuvres

Accuracy and Performance Evaluation of Low Density Internal and External Flow Predictions using CFD and DSMC

Studies of Transonic Aircraft Flows and Prediction of Initial Buffet Onset Using Large-Eddy Simulations

Computational Fluid Dynamics Analyses of a Wing with Distributed Electric Propulsion

Turbulence Resolving Flow Simulations of a Francis Turbine in Part Load using Highly Parallel CFD Simulations

Comparison of different fidelity aerodynamic solvers on the IEA 10 MW turbine including novel tip extension geometries

Improved Self-Adaptive Turbulence Eddy Simulation for Complex Flows and Stall Prediction Using High-Order Schemes

Development of a steady-state computational fluid dynamics solver for transonic rotorcraft flows

Validation and Verification of RANS Solvers for TUDa-GLR-OpenStage Transonic Axial Compressor

Accuracy and Computational Cost Comparison of Numerical Flight Dynamics Reduced-Order Models

Deep Neural Network Modeling for CFD Simulations: Benchmarking the Fourier Neural Operator on the Lid-Driven Cavity Case