Abstract:Context: Effective management of environmental risks such as food and water contamination requires both high quality scientific information and effective, informed social policy. Not only must health practitioners and policy-makers recognize the complexities of human health as a social phenomenon, they must also negotiate the vagaries of uncertainty, precaution, and ethics in their implementation of public health guidelines and advisories. For example, some health practitioners in Alaska have argued against implementation of US Environmental Protection Agency and World Health Organization's standardized consumption advisories for methylmercury (MeHg) in fish, in favor of place-based approaches to evaluating and communicating risk. They stress the importance of traditional subsistence foods and lifestyles, along with other local environmental, economic, and cultural drivers and determinants of environmental health. Such place-based approaches have been successful in improving health outcomes in Alaska and elsewhere. Issue: Nevertheless, debate continues regarding the validity and ethics of place-based approaches to developing and communicating standards and advice for managing environmental risks. Recent critiques suggest that place-based approaches to environmental health represent an undesirable kind of regional 'exceptionalism': the implication of which is that precaution, in respect to acting on the best available objective science, is undermined by attention to subjective local values. In this article we comment on this debate, a debate rooted in concerns regarding the delineation between science-based and policy-based decision-making. Lessons learned: Our experience with the social and ecological dimensions of MeHg contamination of fish and game in Alaska and elsewhere offers three considerations regarding the potential benefits available through place-based approaches: (1) they can contribute to the accuracy and systematic characterization of risks and their relationship to multiple direct and indirect health outcomes; (2) they are more likely to inform actual changes in behavior; and (3) they afford greater transparency to the risk management process and therefore facilitate environmental justice. We stress that standardized risk assessments and advisories remain important for providing a precautionary baseline that can inform the management and enforcement of industrial and other polluting activities at the state level. However, the management of environmental health at the regional and local level requires an approach that is cognizant of local circumstances and needs, and addresses health in a systemic and integrative fashion capable of incorporating qualitative social, cultural, and economic drivers and determinants. Thus, we recommend a two-tiered approach that blends state-based and place-based environmental risk management.

Food, bodies, health (risks): the biopolitics of organic materiality testing in the context of diet-associated health risk management practices

Understanding the role of the state in dietary public health policymaking: a critical scoping review

Public Perceptions of Food Safety: Assessing the RisksPosed by Genetic Modification, Irradiation, Pesticides,Microbiological Contamination and High Fat/High CalorieFoods

Social class, anxieties and mothers' foodwork

Social Implications of Weight Bias Internalisation: Parents' Ultimate Responsibility as Consent, Social Division and Resistance

' The company is using the credibility of our profession ': exploring experiences and perspectives of registered dietitians from Canada about their interactions with commercial actors using semi-structured interviews

Illicit food: Canadian food safety regulation and informal food economy

Unintended consequences in traffic-light food labeling: A call for mixed methods in public health research

Cultural Influences on the Regulation of Energy Intake and Obesity: A Qualitative Study Comparing Food Customs and Attitudes to Eating in Adults from France and the United States

Escaping the Red Queen: Health as a corporate food marketing strategy

‘We must have a sufficient level of profitability’: food industry submissions to the French parliamentary inquiry on industrial food

Strategies used by the Canadian food and beverage industry to influence food and nutrition policies

A focused ethnographic study on the role of health and sustainability in food choice decisions

Beyond individual responsibility: Exploring lay understandings of the contribution of environments on personal trajectories of obesity

Paradigm-Specific Risk Conceptions, Patient Safety, and the Regulation of Traditional and Complementary Medicine Practitioners: The Case of Homeopathy in Ontario, Canada

A vision for safer food contact materials: Public health concerns as drivers for improved testing

The Role of Risk Analysis in EU Food Governance: Balancing Scientific Food Safety Factors and External Factors that Inform Risk Management for Healthier Food Systems

Managing environmental risks: the benefits of a place-based approach

Scientific boundary work and food regime transitions: the double movement and the science of food safety regulation

Governing Consumer Information in the Digital Age: Lessons from a Controversy Between a Food Rating App and Processed Meat Manufacturers

"I Don't Understand How These Two Things Go Together": Toward a Theory of Risk Ecologies