Abstract:Introduction: Metastases increase the risk of fracture when affecting the femur. Consequently, clinicians need to know if the patient's femur can withstand the stress of daily activities. The current tools used in clinics are not sufficiently precise. A new method, the CT-scan-based finite element analysis, gives good predictive results. However, none of the existing models were tested for reproducibility. This is a critical issue to address in order to apply the technique on a large cohort around the world to help evaluate bone metastatic fracture risk in patients. The aim of this study is then to evaluate 1) the reproducibility 2) the transposition of the reproduced model to another dataset and 3) the global sensitivity of one of the most promising models of the literature (original model). Methods: The model was reproduced based on the paper describing it and discussion with authors to avoid reproduction errors. The reproducibility was evaluated by comparing the results given in the original model by the original first team (Leuven, Belgium) and the reproduced model made by another team (Lyon, France) on the same dataset of CT-scans of ex vivo femurs. The transposition of the model was evaluated by comparing the results of the reproduced model on two different datasets. The global sensitivity analysis was done by using the Morris method and evaluates the influence of the density calibration coefficient, the segmentation, the orientations and the length of the femur. Results: The original and reproduced models are highly correlated (r2 = 0.95), even though the reproduced model gives systematically higher failure loads. When using the reproduced model on another dataset, predictions are less accurate (r2 with the experimental failure load decreases, errors increase). The global sensitivity analysis showed high influence of the density calibration coefficient (mean variation of failure load of 84 %) and non-negligible influence of the segmentation, orientation and length of the femur (mean variation of failure load between 7 and 10 %). Conclusion: This study showed that, although being validated, the reproduced model underperformed when using another dataset. The difference in performance depending on the dataset is commonly the cause of overfitting when creating the model. However, the dataset used in the original paper (Sas et al., 2020a) and the Leuven's dataset gave similar performance, which indicates a lesser probability for the overfitting cause. Also, the model is highly sensitive to density parameters and automation of measurement may minimize the uncertainty on failure load. An uncertainty propagation analysis would give the actual precision of such model and improve our understanding of its behavior and is part of future work.

Population-specific femur models: A step towards improved osteosynthetic biomechanical testing in orthopaedics

Biomechanical validation of novel polyurethane-resin synthetic osteoporotic femoral bones in axial compression, four-point bending and torsion

Anatomic variability of the human femur and its implications for the use of artificial bones in biomechanical testing

Developing Patient-Specific Statistical Reconstructions of Healthy Anatomical Structures to Improve Patient Outcomes

Influence of aging on mechanical properties of the femoral neck using an inverse method

Patient-specific mechanical analysis of pedicle screw insertion in simulated osteoporotic spinal bone models derived from medical images

3D Printing and Computer-Aided Design for Precision Osteotomy-Aided Modules in Bone Biomechanical Study

Bone Surface Reconstruction and Clinical Features Estimation from Sparse Landmarks and Statistical Shape Models: A feasibility study on the femur

Assessment of implant internal stresses under physiological femoral loading: Translation to a simplified bending load model

Semi-automated finite element analyses of surgically treated acetabular fractures to investigate the biomechanical behaviour of patient-specific compared to conventional implants

Development of bone surrogates by material extrusion-based additive manufacturing to mimic flexural mechanical behaviour and fracture prediction via phase-field approach

Experimental and virtual testing of bone-implant systems equipped with the AO Fracture Monitor with regard to interfragmentary movement

Inter-laboratory replicability and sensitivity study of a finite element model to quantify human femur failure load: case of metastases

How accurately do finite element models predict the fall impact response of ex vivo specimens augmented by prophylactic intramedullary nailing?

Influence of different sizes of composite femora on the biomechanical behavior of cementless hip prosthesis

Computational biomechanical study on hybrid implant materials for the femoral component of total knee replacements

Inter-laboratory reproduction and sensitivity study of a finite element model to quantify human femur failure load: Case of metastases

Development of a strain rate dependent material model of human cortical bone for computer-aided reconstruction of injury mechanisms

Additive-manufactured synthetic bone model with biomimicking tunable mechanical properties for evaluation of medical implants

A multi-scale modelling framework combining musculoskeletal rigid-body simulations with adaptive finite element analyses, to evaluate the impact of femoral geometry on hip joint contact forces and femoral bone growth

Open the pores – Polydimethylsiloxane influences the porous structure of cancellous bone surrogates for biomechanical testing of osteosyntheses