Addressing barriers and identifying facilitators to support informed consent and recruitment in the Cavernous malformations A Randomised Effectiveness (CARE) pilot phase trial: insights from the integrated QuinteT recruitment intervention (QRI)
Julia Wade,Nicola Farrar,Alba X Realpe,Jenny L Donovan,Laura Forsyth,Kirsty A Harkness,Peter J A Hutchinson,Neil Kitchen,Steff C Lewis,James J M Loan,Jacqueline Stephen,Rustam Al-Shahi Salman,CARE pilot trial collaboration,Conor Mallucci,Philip M White,Madeleine Eriksson,Raza Hayat,Elaine Kinsella,Katherine Lewis,Aileen R Neilson,David Cs White,Julia Boyd,Alastair Bullen,Morag Maclean,Andrew Stoddart,Sandra Phair,Helen Evans,Jo Noakes,Debra Alexander,Catriona Keerie,Christopher Linsley,Garry Milne,John Norrie,Janet Bunch,Kathryn Douthwaite,Simon Temple,James Hogg,David Scott,Pat Spallone,Ian Stuart,Joanna M Wardlaw,Jeb Palmer,Eleni Sakka,Nitin Mukerji,Emanuel Cirstea,Susan Davies,Venetia Giannakaki,Ammar Kadhim,Oliver Kennion,Moidul Islam,Lucie Ferguson,Manjunath Prasad,Andrew Bacon,Emma Richards,Jo Howe,Christine Kamara,Jonathan Gardner,Madalina Roman,Mary Sikaonga,Julian Cahill,Alex Rossdeutsch,Varduhi Cahill,Imron Hamina,Kishor Chaudhari,Mihai Danciut,Emma Clarkson,Anna Bjornson,Diederik Bulters,Ronneil Digpal,Winnington Ruiz,Mirriam Taylor,Divina Anyog,Katarzyna Tluchowska,Jackson Nolasco,Daniel Brooks,Kleopatra Angelopoulou,Bethany Welch,Nicole Broomes,Ioannis Fouyas,Allan MacRaild,Chandru Kaliaperumal,Jessica Teasdale,Michelle Coakley,Paul Brennan,Drahoslav Sokol,Anthony Wiggins,Mairi MacDonald,Sarah Risbridger,Pragnesh Bhatt,Janice Irvine,Sohail Majeed,Sandra Williams,John Reid,Annika Walch,Farah Muir,Janneke van Beijnum,Paul Leach,Tom Hughes,Milan Makwana,Khalid Hamandi,Dympna McAleer,Belinda Gunning,Daniel Walsh,Oliver Wroe Wright,Sabina Patel,Nihal Gurusinghe,Saba Raza-Knight,Terri-Louise Cromie,Allan Brown,Sonia Raj,Ruth Pennington,Charlene Campbell,Shakeelah Patel,Francesca Colombo,Mario Teo,Jack Wildman,Kerry Smith,Elizabeth Goff,Deanna Stephens,Borislava Borislavova,Ruth Worner,Sandeep Buddha,Philip Clatworthy,Richard Edwards,Evangeline Clayton,Karen Coy,Lisa Tucker,Sandra Dymond,Andrew Mallick,Rebecca Hodnett,Francesca Spickett-Jones,Patrick Grover,Azra Banaras,Sifelani Tshuma,William Muirhead,Ciaran Scott Hill,Rupal Shah,Thomas Doke,Rebecca Hall,Sonny Coskuner,Laura Aslett,Raghu Vindlacheruvu,Anthony Ghosh,Teresa Fitzpatrick,Lauren Harris,Tom Hayton,Arlo Whitehouse,Andrew McDarby,Rebecca Hancox,Claudia Kate Auyeung,Ramesh Nair,Rhys Thomas,Heather McLachlan,Athanasia Kountourgioti,Guillelme Orjales,Jan Kruczynski,Sophie Hunter,Niamh Bohnacker,Rosette Marimon,Lydia Parker,Oishik Raha,Puneet Sharma,Christopher Uff,Geetha Boyapati,Marios Papadopoulos,Siobhan Kearney,Ravindran Visagan,Ellaine Bosetta,Hasan Asif,Adel Helmy,Liliana Chapas,Silvia Tarantino,Karen Caldwell,Mathew Guilfoyle,Smriti Agarwal,Daniel Brown,Sarah Holland,Tamara Tajsic,Clare Fletcher,Aisha Sebyatki,Shungu Ushewokunze,Sarah Ali,John Preston,Carole Chambers,Mohammed Patel,Daniel Holsgrove,Danielle McLaughlan,Tracey Marsden,Kathryn Cawley,Hellen Raffalli,Stephanie Lee,Anil Israni,Rachael Dore,Taya Anderson,Dawn Hennigan,Shelley Mayor,Samantha Glover,Emmanuel Chavredakis,Debbie Brown,Giannis Sokratous,John Williamson,Cathy Stoneley,Andrew Brodbelt,Jibril Osman Farah,Sarah Illingworth,Anastasios Benjamin Konteas,Deborah Davies,Carol Owen,Loretta Kerr
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eclinm.2024.102557
IF: 15.1
2024-04-18
EClinicalMedicine
Abstract:Background: It was anticipated that recruitment to the Cavernous malformations: A Randomised Effectiveness (CARE) pilot randomised trial would be challenging. The trial compared medical management and surgery (neurosurgical resection or stereotactic radiosurgery) with medical management alone, for people with symptomatic cerebral cavernous malformation (ISRCTN41647111). Previous trials comparing surgical and medical management for intracranial vascular malformations failed to recruit to target. A QuinteT Recruitment Intervention was integrated during trial accrual, September 2021-April 2023 inclusive, to improve informed consent and recruitment. Methods: The QuinteT Recruitment Intervention combined iterative collection and analysis of quantitative data (28 trial site screening logs recording numbers/proportions screened, eligible, approached and randomised) and qualitative data (79 audio-recorded recruitment discussions, 19 interviews with healthcare professionals, 11 interviews with patients, 2 investigator workshops, and observations of study meetings, all subject to thematic, content or conversation analysis). We triangulated quantitative and qualitative data to identify barriers and facilitators to recruitment and how and why these arose. Working with the chief investigators and trial management group, we addressed barriers and facilitators with corresponding actions to improve informed consent and recruitment. Findings: Barriers identified included how usual care practices made equipoise challenging, multi-disciplinary teams sometimes overrode recruiter equipoise and logistical issues rendered symptomatic cavernoma diagnosis and assessment for stereotactic radiosurgery challenging. Facilitators identified included the preparedness of some neurosurgeons' to offer surgery to people otherwise offered medical management alone, multi-disciplinary team equipoise, and effective information provision presenting participation as a solution to equipoise regarding management. Actions, before and during recruitment, to improve inclusivity of site screening, approach and effectiveness of information provision resulted in 72 participants recruited following a 5-month extension, exceeding the target of 60 participants. Interpretation: QuinteT Recruitment Intervention insights revealed barriers and facilitators, enabling identification of remedial actions. Recruitment to a definitive trial would benefit from further training/support to encourage clinicians to be comfortable approaching patients to whom medical management is usually offered, and broadening the pool of neurosurgeons and multi-disciplinary team members prepared to offer surgery, particularly stereotactic radiosurgery. Funding: National Institute for Health and Care Research.