Institutional trading in volatile markets: Evidence from Chinese stock markets

Julia Darby,Hai Zhang,Jinkai Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pacfin.2020.101484

2021-02-01

Abstract:<p>We investigate the daily stock returns of all A-shares listed on the Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchanges over the period 2010–2017. Using daily cash flow data on the largest category of trades by value, we construct a proxy for high-value institutional trading activity. We demonstrate that high-value institutional transactions consistently exacerbate firm-level abnormal stock returns on extreme market movement days. We then highlight the conflating influence of regulator imposed daily limits on firm-level stock price movements and conclude that binding price limits act to exacerbate the destabilizing effects associated with high-value institutional trades in Chinese stock markets.</p>

business, finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the following issue: whether institutional trading in the Chinese stock market exacerbates abnormal returns of individual stocks during periods of extreme market volatility, and how the price limits set by regulators affect this effect.

### Main Issues Addressed by the Paper:
1. **Impact of Institutional Trading on Extreme Market Volatility**:
- By constructing a high-value trading proxy variable based on daily cash flow data, the study investigates whether institutional trading during periods of extreme market volatility (such as days of significant market rises or falls) leads to abnormal returns for individual stocks.
- This proxy variable can more accurately capture the details of institutional trading behavior, compared to previous studies that relied on quarterly data.

2. **Role of Price Limits**:
- In the Chinese stock market, regulators have set a daily price limit of ±10%. The paper explores how these price limits affect the performance of individual stocks during periods of extreme market volatility and whether these limits exacerbate or mitigate market instability caused by high-value institutional trading.
- The study also examines whether there is a delay or reversal in the price discovery process in the days following a stock hitting its price limit.

### Research Background:
- The Chinese stock market has rapidly developed since the 1990s and has become the world's second-largest capital market.
- Extreme market volatility and seemingly irrational behavior have drawn the attention of policymakers, regulators, and global investors.
- Previous literature (such as Dennis and Strickland 2002, Tian et al. 2018) has studied institutional trading behavior but mostly relied on quarterly data, which cannot capture the details of daily trading behavior.

### Main Contributions:
1. **Improved Institutional Trading Proxy Variable**:
- A new proxy variable is constructed using daily cash flow data to more accurately reflect institutional trading activity.
2. **Impact of Price Limits**:
- Emphasizes the important role of price limits on the performance of individual stocks during periods of extreme market volatility.
3. **Prediction of Subsequent Days' Performance**:
- Investigates whether high-value institutional trading during periods of extreme market volatility can predict abnormal returns of individual stocks in subsequent days.

Through this research, the paper aims to provide new evidence on the stability of the Chinese stock market and institutional trading behavior for policymakers and market participants.