Assessing Performance of Alternative Pavement Marking Materials

Haoqiang Fu,C. Wilmot
2008-08-01
Abstract:Pavement markings need to be restriped from time to time to maintain retroreflectivity. Knowing which material provides the most economically efficient solution is important. Currently, no agreed upon method by which to evaluate the use of alternative pavement marking materials exists. This study developed a methodology that measures the benefit of pavement marking materials based on the public perceived benefit of retroreflectivity. Using the measured benefit along with the cost of installation and impact on road users during the installation process, a benefit/cost analysis was applied to evaluate different marking materials used on Louisiana interstate freeways, including thermoplastics (both 40 mil and 90 mil), tape, and inverted profile pavement markings. A Microsoft Excel workbook with built-in macros, named PMValue.xlsm, was developed to allow the comparison of alternative pavement marking materials for a particular application. A simple and user friendly interface enables users to specify basic information about the pavement, traffic conditions, material cost, and application schedule. Results of the analysis are presented in graphical form to assist users in assessing the performance of alternative pavement marking materials in terms of their benefit/cost ratio. The impact of increasing the starting and six-month retroreflectivity specifications for 90 mil and tape was also estimated. The impact was measured in terms of increased pavement marking service life. The percentage of current markings that would fail the new requirement, based on current data, was also observed. An alternative specification in which the initial retroreflectivity specification is followed by a maximum percent decrease from the initial retroreflectivity in six months was also considered. The suggested specification not only sets the standard for initial retroreflectivity but also sets a limit on the decay rate of retroreflectivity.
Environmental Science,Engineering
What problem does this paper attempt to address?