Short-Term Reproduction of Active Movement with Visual Feedback and Passive Movement with a Therapist's Hands

Hitoshi Oda,Shiho Fukuda,Ryo Tsujinaka,Han Gao,Koichi Hiraoka

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/brainsci14060531

IF: 3.333

2024-05-24

Brain Sciences

Abstract:Reproducing instructed movements is crucial for practice in motor learning. In this study, we compared the short-term reproduction of active pelvis movements with visual feedback and passive movement with the therapist's hands in an upright stance. Sixteen healthy males (M age = 34.1; SD = 10.2 years) participated in this study. In one condition, healthy males maintained an upright stance while a physical therapist moved the participant's pelvis (passive movement instruction), and in a second condition, the participant actively moved their pelvis with visual feedback of the target and the online trajectory of the center of pressure (active movement instruction). Reproduction errors (displacement of the center of pressure in the medial–lateral axis) 10 s after the passive movement instruction were significantly greater than after the active movement instruction (p < 0.001), but this difference disappeared 30 s after the instruction (p = 0.118). Error of movement reproduction in the anterior–posterior axis after the passive movement instruction was significantly greater than after the active movement instruction, no matter how long the retention interval was between the instruction and reproduction phases (p = 0.025). Taken together, active pelvis movements with visual feedback, rather than passive movement with the therapist's hand, is better to be used for instructing pelvis movements.

neurosciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the difference in the ability to reproduce the instructed movement in a short time between active pelvic movement (with visual feedback) and passive pelvic movement (guided by the therapist's hands) in the standing posture. Specifically, the researchers compared the short - term memory and reproduction ability of participants for pelvic movement under two different conditions (active movement and passive movement) to determine which method is more suitable for guiding the learning and rehabilitation training of pelvic movement.

### Research Background
- **Exercises for patients with movement disorders**: For patients with movement disorders, it is very important to improve their movement control by practicing the movements that need to be learned. The way of giving movement instructions is crucial to the ease or effectiveness of patients' learning.
- **The role of passive movement**: Passive movement refers to the therapist moving a certain part of the patient's body by hand, so that the patient can perceive and understand the movement to be learned through proprioception. This technique is especially suitable for patients who are unable to move autonomously or move correctly.
- **Comparison between active movement and passive movement**: Although previous studies have shown that passive movement is beneficial for movement learning, the relative effects of active movement and passive movement on movement instructions have not been clearly determined through empirical research.

### Research Purpose
This paper aims to compare the effects of active pelvic movement (with visual feedback) and passive pelvic movement (guided by the therapist's hands) on reproducing the instructed movement in the short term through experiments, so as to determine which method is more suitable for guiding the learning and rehabilitation training of pelvic movement.

### Main Findings
- **Error on the transverse axis**: During the retention interval after 10 seconds, the reproduction error under the passive movement condition was significantly greater than that under the active movement condition (\( p < 0.001 \)), but this difference disappeared after 30 seconds (\( p = 0.118 \)).
- **Error on the anteroposterior axis**: Regardless of the length of the retention interval, the anteroposterior axis reproduction error under the passive movement condition was always significantly greater than that under the active movement condition (\( p = 0.025 \)).

In conclusion, the research results show that in the short term, active pelvic movement with visual feedback is more effective in guiding the learning and reproduction of pelvic movement than passive pelvic movement guided by the therapist's hands.