Urban ecological risk transmission model based on Bayesian network

Wen Zhang,Gengyuan Liu,Qing Yang,Zhifeng Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.126559

IF: 11.1

2021-05-01

Journal of Cleaner Production

Abstract:<p>Simulating this ecological risk transmission process helps to judge the key path and propose the accurate urban risk control measures. This paper develops an urban ecological risk transmission conceptual framework based on Bayesian Network to quantify the non-linear transmission paths via HA (human activity) — ES (ecosystem service) — ER (ecological risk). Ecosystem services are used as ecological risk measurement endpoints to quantify service provision and possible adverse effects from human activities. Direct and indirect impacts of urban human activities that threaten ecosystem services were considered. Nine cities in the Pearl River Delta (China) are selected as a case to simulate the ecological risk transmission process. Results show that: (1) Zhongshan and Guangzhou tied for the city most at ecological risk and Foshan jumped to the city with the highest ecological risk after considering the impact of pollution; (2) After analyzing the sensitive of human activities to ecological risks, the key risk transmission path of each city can be judged. There are three types of key paths: pollution dominant path (including Guangzhou, Foshan, Dongguan and Zhuhai), ES dominant path (including Shenzhen, Zhongshan and Jiangmen) and dual dominant path (including Zhaoqing and Huizhou); (3) Buildup area, afforestation area and wetland protection &amp; restoration investment are the top three key human activities that impact the urban ecological risk. Adjusting these key variables can be simulated to effectively reduce the urban ecological risk. The model can be used as a useful tool to guide policy and risk management decisions, and to engage and negotiate with stakeholders with different views.</p>

environmental sciences,green & sustainable science & technology,engineering, environmental

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is the transmission paths of urban ecological risks and their key driving factors. Specifically, the article aims to quantify the non - linear transmission paths among human activities (HA), ecosystem services (ES) and ecological risks (ER) by constructing an urban ecological risk transmission model based on Bayesian networks, and identify the key risk transmission paths, so as to propose effective urban ecological risk management measures.

### Background of the Paper and Problem Description

With the acceleration of the urbanization process, the pressure on urban ecosystems has been continuously increasing, resulting in a series of ecological problems, such as land degradation, vegetation destruction, environmental pollution, sharp decline in biodiversity and ecological imbalance. Traditional ecological risk assessment methods mainly focus on the characteristic indicators of ecological entities, such as point - source threats and changes in regional landscape patterns, while ignoring the functional attributes closely related to human well - being. Therefore, a new method is needed to comprehensively consider the impact of human activities on ecosystems, especially from the perspective of the ecological risk transmission process for assessment.

### Solutions

To address the above problems, the author proposes a conceptual framework for urban ecological risk transmission based on Bayesian networks. The main features of this framework are as follows:

1. **Risk Factor Identification**: Through qualitative analysis methods, determine each element participating in the risk transmission process, and use certain variables to represent each element.
2. **Risk Transmission Process Simulation**: Taking the ecosystem as the main perspective, use matrix analysis to establish a preliminary structure, and on this basis, construct the corresponding risk transmission network model. Use the Bayesian network model to simulate the risk transmission process and analyze the transmission rules from the risk perspective.
3. **Identification of Key Control Variables**: Identify the key variables that play an important role in the risk transmission process, which is crucial for constructing a risk control strategy based on the urban socio - ecological system. Adjusting these key variables can effectively reduce ecological risks, but may have unpredictable impacts on the system.

### Research Cases

The article selected nine cities in the Pearl River Delta in China as research cases to simulate the ecological risk transmission process. The results show that:
- Zhongshan and Guangzhou are tied for the cities with the highest ecological risks, and Foshan has risen to the city with the highest ecological risk due to pollution impacts.
- Analyzed the sensitivity of human activities to ecological risks and identified three types of key paths: pollution - dominated paths (including Guangzhou, Foshan, Dongguan and Zhuhai), ES - dominated paths (including Shenzhen, Zhongshan and Jiangmen), and dual - dominated paths (including Zhaoqing and Huizhou).
- The building area, afforestation area and wetland protection and restoration investment are the three key human activities that affect urban ecological risks. Adjusting these key variables can effectively reduce urban ecological risks.

### Model Advantages

The Bayesian network model has the following advantages:
- **Flexibility**: The conceptual model can be easily converted into a BN structure through causal relationships.
- **Flexible Parameter Estimation Methods**: It can combine quantitative and qualitative methods to estimate parameters, which is suitable for ecosystem research with scarce data.
- **Complex Network Modeling Ability**: It can simulate the correlations between different components in the ecosystem and identify key paths and key factors.

### Conclusions

This study provides an effective tool for guiding policy and risk management decisions and provides a basis for negotiation for stakeholders with different views. By adjusting key paths and key factors, an ecological management strategy for keeping urban ecological risks at a certain low level is proposed.

### Formula Examples

Among some formulas and calculation methods mentioned in the article, for example, the calculation of ecosystem service value (ESV) can be expressed as:

\[ ESV=\sum_{i = 1}^{n}(Q_{i}\times P_{i})\]

where:
- \(Q_{i}\) represents the quantity of the \(i\) - th ecosystem service;
- \(P_{i}\) represents the unit price of the \(i\) - th ecosystem service;
- \(n\) represents the total number of ecosystem service types.

Hopefully, this information can help you better understand the research purposes and methods of this paper. If you have more questions or need further information, please feel free to let us know.