Photon counting and color X-ray imaging in standard CIS technology
N. Ahmed,B. Dierickx,B. Dupont
Abstract:With the extensive usage of radiography in many medical diagnosis protocols, the urge to achieve the lowest possible dose imaging is a driving force for the X-ray image sensor community. The ultimate signal to noise ratio that one can theoretically achieve is the quantum limit, where each and every photon reaching the imager is counted. Moreover, photon counting comes with an additional benefit: the possibility to sort incoming X-ray photons based on their energy, achieving “color X-ray” imaging, a real added value for the diagnostician. This is a compilation of previous publications by Caeleste and public information. Why color X-ray imaging? The clinician’s point of view The present state of the art digital radiography (DR) is made of low noise charge integration pixels, either made of monocrystalline (CCD, CMOS) or amorphous (TFT) Silicon, combined with scintillation or direct detection material. With the strong focus on dose reduction, the main R&D area has been the lowering of the noise floor. The “charge integration” images are radiation intensity coded, and bear no energy information. Visualization equipment can of course render “false colors”, but this does not have the added diagnostic value of true color X-ray. True color X-ray imaging is an advantage for the clinician. Applications range from medical diagnostics, bone densitometry, mammography. We recently participated in a study, led by the Departments of AnatomoPathology and of Radiology of the Universitair Ziekenhuis Brussels (UZB), showing that Multi-energy X-ray has an enhanced visibility of tumor tissues in mammography [1][2][3]. Double blind tests have demonstrated that in 23% of the cases, the traditional X-ray picture underestimate the stage of the tumor compared to the color X-ray with energy discrimination. Color X-ray also revealed multifocal lesions that were missed by the classical method [3]. The physicist’s point of view Essentially color X-ray images have the capability to sort tissue or material based on their chemical atomic composition. As X-ray spectral absorption depends largely on the element’s (atom’s) Z-number, one can by examination of the absorbed of transmitted spectrum deduce information on the relative concentration of the elements. This is explained in Figure 1 where the spectral absorption of the most prevalent elements in biological tissue is shown. In biological tissue one major type of information is the ratio of Carbon over Oxygen. As an example, a comparison of mammary resection specimen, in X-ray black & white (B&W) and color images are shown in Figure 2 and Figure 3. Today’s X-ray equipment allows dual and multiple energy X-ray imaging by dual or multiple exposure with different energy spectra. This is an acceptable technique on operation specimen, but widespread use in medical imaging is precluded by the additional radiation dose due to the multiple exposure. The ideal way to obtain multi-energy information in the X-ray image is by energy-classifying the photons as they arrive, within the same single and original exposure.
Engineering,Medicine,Physics