Deterrents intended to mitigate mining effects mostly fail to change nesting behavior of Arctic breeding birds

Gill Holmes,Erica Nol,Paul Smith

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5751/ace-02714-190217

2024-10-22

Avian Conservation and Ecology

Abstract:Mining is an important economic driver in the Arctic and leads to land-use changes and habitat loss for Arctic breeding birds. Various techniques are used to mitigate the impacts of extractive mining on wildlife, including deterrents designed to keep wildlife away from activities that may cause harm to animals. This study assessed the efficacy of deterrents intended to prevent birds from nesting in tundra areas that were planned for flooding during mining pit expansion. We used visual and audio deterrents (flash tape and hawk effigies, as well as predator and prey distress calls) to attempt to discourage nesting by birds at a gold mine north of Baker Lake, Nunavut. We used a before-after control-impact design to determine changes in birds' territory densities before and after deployment of deterrent treatments. We assessed whether deterrent intensity had an impact on nest survival of the most common passerines, Lapland Longspur ( Calcarius lapponicus ), Horned Lark ( Eremophila alpestris ), and shorebirds, Semipalmated Sandpiper ( Calidris pusilla ), and Least Sandpiper ( Calidris minutilla ), because of the potential for deterrents to increase disturbance to incubating birds. Using temperature probes inserted into nests, we also determined whether deterrents influenced incubation behavior of Lapland Longspurs. Deterrents did not impact territory densities except in dissuading Horned Larks. Deterrents did not result in lower nest survival of passerines or shorebirds, nor did deterrents affect the frequency of incubation recesses for incubating Lapland Longspur females. We conclude that, in general, the deterrents used in this study were not effective at preventing birds from using treatment areas, and therefore we advise against the use of these techniques for mitigating the effects of mine flooding for Arctic-nesting birds. The post Deterrents intended to mitigate mining effects mostly fail to change nesting behavior of Arctic breeding birds first appeared on Avian Conservation and Ecology.

biodiversity conservation,ornithology