Abstract:We investigated community structure and species co‐occurrence patterns in Great Lakes coastal wetlands benthic macroinvertebrates using null models. We developed a framework and approach to address recent controversy over the use of presence‐absence matrices and null models to infer ecological interactions from non‐random co‐occurrence patterns using community data collected over thirteen years from 172 sites across the Great Lakes basin. Very few communities showed non‐random co‐occurrence patterns; however, the majority of non‐random situations contained invertebrate taxa known to over‐winter. We discuss how these taxa may be driving the negative co‐occurrence patterns we detected and suggest that results from presence absence matrices and null model analysis could be used as an early warning system in the face of climate change. In niche‐based community assembly theory, it is presumed that communities in habitats with high natural disturbance regimes are less likely to be structured by competitive mechanisms. Laurentian Great Lakes (hereafter Great Lakes) coastal wetlands can experience drastic diel fluctuations in dissolved oxygen levels, severe wave action, ice scour, and near complete freezing during the winter such that conditions are inhospitable for most organisms. The high natural disturbance levels are thought to cause high interannual turnover for aquatic macroinvertebrate communities and support the hypothesis that these communities are less likely to experience less competitive interactions and negative co‐occurrence structure. We hypothesize that non‐random co‐occurrence patterns will be rare in Great Lake coastal wetlands and non‐competitive processes (e.g., through shared or differential microhabitat affinities, pollution tolerances, or biotic homogenization) will be more common than competitively driven negative co‐occurrence patterns. Null model analysis was performed on 134 macroinvertebrate communities sampled from across the Great Lakes basin from 2000 to 2013. To disentangle the effects of alternative structuring mechanisms (i.e., shared/differential habitat affinities, shared/differential pollution tolerance, and biological homogenization/competitive exclusion), communities were parsed based on the year sampled, the vegetation type from which community samples were collected, and lastly species' functional feeding group assignment or taxonomic group. As expected, very few communities were non‐randomly structured; however, all of those that were non‐random exhibited showed more negative co‐occurrences than by chance. Upon further investigation, these communities consisted of species that are known to overwinter in wetlands, and therefore, avoid having to recolonize after each spring thaw. With expected changes in habitat conditions due to climate change, we propose that null model analyses can be used as an early warning system for community change.

Effect of sampling intensity on understanding species co-occurrence pattern of fish community using null model analysis

Sampling intensity influences the estimation of functional diversity indices of fish communities

The Effects of Sampling-Site Intervals on Fish Species Richness in Wadeable Rivers: A Case Study from Taizi River Basin, Northeastern China

Effectively Inferring Overall Spatial Distribution Pattern of Species in a Map when Exact Coordinate Information is Missing

No Evidence For The Small-Island Effect In Avian Communities On Islands Of An Inundated Lake

Coupled space-time scale analysis for obtaining enhanced accuracy in species dynamics

Testing Multiple Assembly Rule Models in Avian Communities on Islands of an Inundated Lake, Zhejiang Province, China

Small-island Effect in Snake Communities on Islands of an Inundated Lake: the Need to Include Zeroes

Quantifying Effects of Habitat Heterogeneity and Other Clustering Processes on Spatial Distributions of Tree Species

Co-occurrence patterns and community assembly mechanisms of benthic foraminiferal communities in South Chinese bays

Deciphering sample size effect on microbial biogeographic patterns and community assembly processes at centimeter scale

The influence of species pools and local processes on the community structure: a test case with woody plant communities in China's mountains

Sampling Designs for Monitoring Ichthyoplankton in the Estuary Area: A Case Study on Coilia mystus in the Yangtze Estuary

Fitting Methods and Seasonality Effects on the Assessment of Pelagic Fish Communities in Daya Bay, China

Diel, seasonal, and annual variations of fish assemblages in intertidal creeks of the Changjiang River estuary

Comparison of Fish, Macroinvertebrates and Diatom Communities in Response to Environmental Variation in the Wei River Basin, China

Functional zeta diversity can better reveal fish metacommunity assembly process in a transitional floodplain

Co‐Occurrence Patterns of Aquatic Macroinvertebrates in Laurentian Great Lakes Coastal Wetlands

Different Relationships Between Temporal Phylogenetic Turnover and Phylogenetic Similarity and in Two Forests Were Detected by a New Null Model.

Elements of metacommunity structure of diatoms and macroinvertebrates within stream networks differing in environmental heterogeneity

Sample size considerations for species co-occurrence models.