Abstract:Research Summary Despite significant national reductions in crime during the past three decades, a comparable reduction in adult arrest rates has not occurred. In addition, scant attention has been paid to the role of the police in pretrial justice and other criminal justice reform efforts, despite their role as gatekeepers to the criminal justice system. A key inquiry that must be addressed by both academics and practitioners is whether it is possible to reduce crime and the number of arrests simultaneously. Cincinnati (Hamilton County), Ohio, provided a unique opportunity to examine this unanswered question when it closed the Queensgate Correctional Facility in 2008, thereby reducing the available jail space in the county by 36%. By relying on an interrupted time‐series analysis, our findings show that contrary to public concern, both crime and arrests were reduced in Cincinnati even after the jail closure. Specifically, the Cincinnati Police Department reported a statistically significant decrease in felony arrests, and a nonsignificant decline in misdemeanor arrests, while maintaining a continued (nonsignificant) decline in violence and property crimes. Importantly, our findings demonstrate that the previous existent downward trend in Cincinnati reported crimes was not interrupted with the loss of more than one third of the available jail space in Hamilton County. Policy Implications Policy makers and practitioners are concerned with balancing the individual rights of the accused with public safety; reducing incarceration; and promoting a more efficient, effective, and fair criminal justice system. The Cincinnati Police Department addressed these fundamental concerns by changing how officers viewed the use of arrest: as a limited commodity rather than as a standard response. By using strategies such as problem‐oriented policing, place‐based policing, and focused deterrence, Cincinnati Police were able to narrow their focus on the repeat places, problems, and groups of individuals that were driving crime within the city. The evidence suggests that the police can have a significant impact on pretrial justice and other criminal justice reform efforts through the implementation of evidence‐based policing strategies that seek to reduce crime and reduce the use of arrest simultaneously.

Decreased Bi-Partisan Support for Pretrial Detention in Less Serious Cases: Evidence From an Experimental Survey

Assessing Risk Assessment in Action

Evidence-based sentencing: Public openness and opposition to using gender, age, and race as risk factors for recidivism.

Predictive Validity of Pretrial Risk Assessments: A Systematic Review of the Literature

An Empirical Evaluation of the Impact of New York's Bail Reform on Crime Using Synthetic Controls

The Impact of Police on Criminal Justice Reform

Public fear of protesters and support for protest policing: An experimental test of two theoretical models*

Impact of risk assessment on judges' fairness in sentencing relatively poor defendants

Experimental Evaluation of Algorithm-Assisted Human Decision-Making: Application to Pretrial Public Safety Assessment

Effects of Conservative Sociopolitical Attitudes on Public Support for Drug Rehabilitation Spending

Justice involvement prediction as individuals age: An age-graded evaluation of the public safety assessment.

Measuring Racial Discrimination in Bail Decisions

Discrimination Against Immigrants in the Criminal Justice System: Evidence from Pretrial Detentions

Do individual characteristics explain variation in sanction risk updating among serious juvenile offenders? Advancing the logic of differential deterrence.

Race and Stereotypes Matter When You Ask About Conduct Problems: Implications for Violence Risk Assessment in Juvenile Justice Settings

Perceptions of Anti-Black Bias in the Criminal Justice System Contribute to Pro-Black (Versus White) Bias in Criminal Justice Research

Public support for second look sentencing: Is there a Shawshank redemption effect?

Understanding the Significance & Complexity of the Brady Rule

Jobs and Punishment: Public Opinion on Leniency for White-Collar Crime

A note on post-treatment selection in studying racial discrimination in policing

Blinding prosecutors to defendants’ race: A policy proposal to reduce unconscious bias in the criminal justice system