Abstract:This study seeks to examine the environmental and societal impacts of a carbon tax in Italy, where the policy has yet to be implemented but has been the subject of much debate. We use numerical simulations based on the EUROGREEN macro-system dynamic model (D'Alessandro et al., 2020) to evaluate the potential benefits and drawbacks of this policy from 2010 to 2050. We employ a sequential scenario approach, starting with a baseline that incorporates Italy's Energetic Plan (PNIEC), followed by the introduction of a gradually increasing carbon tax. Additionally, we test two hypotheses regarding the possible adaptive behaviors of consumers and producers in response to the policy. Our analysis evaluates the long-term impacts of the carbon tax on GDP, unemployment, public debt, carbon emissions, and income inequality, in pursuit of a "quadruple-dividend" effect. Our findings suggest that the carbon tax: ( i ) has a limited impact on reducing carbon emissions, with a difference of only 2% compared to the PNIEC by 2050, ( ii ) has the potential to mitigate regressive effects through the redistribution of its revenue to low-income households, resulting in an improvement of approximately 2 Gini-points compared to the PNIEC, and ( iii ) can achieve a quadruple-dividend effect only if consumers and industries adapt their behavior to the policy. Our research argues that Italy could reap the benefits of a carbon tax, with the revenue being redistributed to low-income households, leading to a more equitable and sustainable energy transition. This can only be achieved by combining top-down policies with bottom-up initiatives and public interventions, making environmental taxation more acceptable to the general public.

Environmental tax reform and double dividend evidence

Environmental Tax Reform and the “Double Dividend” Hypothesis in a Small Open Economy

Introduction of the carbon tax in Italy: Is there room for a quadruple-dividend effect?

Environmental Policy and ‘double Dividend’ in a Transitional Economy

Effect of Environmental Taxes on Carbon Dioxide Emissions in Europe

Involuntary Unemployment and Environmental Policy: The Double Dividend Hypothesis

A computable general equilibrium analysis of environmental tax reform in Japan with a forward-looking dynamic model

The Environmental Tax: Effects on Inequality and Growth

Economic impact of the carbon tax: Evaluation of the reduction in CO2 emissions

How do governments actually use environmental taxes?

Environmental Taxes under Mixed Duopoly: the Roles of Privatization and Foreign Eco-Technology

Double Dividend of the Carbon Tax in Japan: Can We Increase Public Support for Carbon Pricing?

Environmental Tax Reform and the European Green Deal: Empirical Evidence from Panel Data Analysis

Energy Taxation Reform with an Environmental Focus in Portugal

Study on the Impact of Environmental Tax on Industrial Green Transformation

Effects of environmental tax reforms in a small open economy

Optimal environmental tax swaps and double dividend hypothesis

Re-evaluating environmental tax: An intergenerational perspective on health, education and retirement

Research on Environmental Tax to Affect the Economic Development and GHG Mitigation in Beijing, China

The Distributional Effects of China'senvironmental Taxation: A Multi-Regional Analysis.

Gathering Support for Green Tax Reform: Evidence from German Household Surveys