Abstract:Abstract Defensive strategies, like other life-history traits favored by natural selection, may pose constraints on reproduction. A common anti-predator defense strategy that increases immediate survival is autotomy—the voluntary release of body parts. This type of morphological damage is considered to impose future costs for reproduction and fitness. We tested an alternative hypothesis that animals are robust (able to withstand and overcome perturbations) to this type of damage and do not experience any fitness costs in reproductive contexts. We explored the effects of experimental leg loss on the reproductive behavior of one species of Neotropical Prionostemma harvestmen. These arachnids undergo autotomy frequently, do not regenerate legs, and their courtship and mating necessitate the use of legs. We assessed the effect of losing different types of legs (locomotor or sensory) on courtship behavior and mating success in males. We found no differences in the mating success or in any measured aspect of reproductive behavior between eight-legged males and males that experienced loss of legs of any type. Additionally, we found that morphological traits related to body size did not predict mating success. Overall, our experimental findings support the null hypothesis that harvestmen are robust to the consequences of morphological damage and natural selection favors strategies that increase robustness. Significance statement In order to survive encounters with predators, animals have evolved many defensive strategies. Some of those behaviors, however, can come with a cost to their overall body condition. For example, some animals can voluntarily lose body parts (tails, legs, etc.) to escape. This process can then affect many aspects of an animal’s life, including reproduction. In a group of harvestmen (daddy long-legs) from Costa Rica, we tested the hypothesis that males are robust to the potential consequences of losing legs, and will not experience costs. We found that males that lost either legs used for locomotion or for sensory perception reproduced in the same way as animals with all of their legs. Consequently, we demonstrate that these arachnids are able to withstand the loss of legs with no effects on reproduction.

Heterospecific interaction in two beetle species: Males with weapons decrease the reproductive success of species with weaponless males

Defining an intrasexual male weapon polymorphism in a New Zealand harvestman (Opiliones: Neopilionidae) using traditional and geometric morphometrics

Weapon performance drives weapon evolution

The evolution of male weapons is associated with the type of breeding site in a clade of Neotropical frogs

Weapon allometry and shape variation in the Helm’s stag beetle ( Geodorcus helmsi)

The role of resource defensibility in facilitating sexually-selected weapon evolution: An experimental evolution test

Induction of male‐like mandibles in XX individuals of a stag beetle by gene knockdown of a feminizer gene transformer

Heterospecific interference modulates the reproductive traits of a ladybird beetle

Relationship between weapon size and six key behavioural and physiological traits in males of the European earwig

Evolution of horn length and lifting strength in the Japanese rhinoceros beetle Trypoxylus dichotomus

The evolution of multi-component weapons in the superfamily of leaf-footed bugs

Experimental quantification of genetic and ontogenetic effects on fighting behavior in the broad-horned flour beetle

Sperm competition and the evolution of precopulatory weapons: Testis size and amplexus position, but not arm strength, affect fertilization success in a chorusing frog

No fitness effects of same‐sex copulations in male red flour beetles

Reduced fitness in losers of leg-biting male combat compared to uncontested males in Zophobas atratus

The effects of reproduction on courtship, fertility and longevity within and between alternative male mating tactics of the horned beetle, Onthophagus binodis

Intra-sexual selection in cooperative mammals and birds: why are females not bigger and better armed?

Genomic evidence that a sexually selected trait captures genome-wide variation and facilitates the purging of genetic load

Comparative analyses of reproductive structures in harvestmen (opiliones) reveal multiple transitions from courtship to precopulatory antagonism

Robustness in action: Leg loss does not affect mating success in male harvestmen

Male is the default sex: functional significance of the sex determination cascade in horned dung beetles