Abstract:Numerous studies have shown that combining populations from similar or closely related genetic breeds improves the accuracy of genomic predictions (GP). Extensive experimentation with diverse Bayesian and genomic best linear unbiased prediction (GBLUP) models have been developed to explore multi-breed genomic selection (GS) in livestock, ultimately establishing them as successful approaches for predicting genomic estimated breeding value (GEBV). This study aimed to assess the effectiveness of using BayesR and GBLUP models with linkage disequilibrium (LD)-weighted genomic relationship matrices (GRMs) for genomic prediction in three different beef cattle breeds to identify the best approach for enhancing the accuracy of multi-breed genomic selection in beef cattle. Additionally, a comparison was conducted to evaluate the predictive precision of different marker densities and genetic correlations among the three breeds of beef cattle. The GRM between Yunling cattle (YL) and other breeds demonstrated modest affinity and highlighted a notable genetic concordance of 0.87 between Chinese Wagyu (WG) and Huaxi (HX) cattle. In the within-breed GS, BayesR demonstrated an advantage over GBLUP. The prediction accuracies for HX cattle using the BayesR model were 0.52 with BovineHD BeadChip data (HD) and 0.46 with whole-genome sequencing data (WGS). In comparison to the GBLUP model, the accuracy increased by 26.8% for HD data and 9.5% for WGS data. For WG and YL, BayesR doubled the within-breed prediction accuracy to 14.3% from 7.1%, outperforming GBLUP across both HD and WGS datasets. Moreover, analyzing multiple breeds using genomic selection showed that BayesR consistently outperformed GBLUP in terms of predictive accuracy, especially when using WGS. For instance, in a mixed reference population of HX and WG, BayesR achieved a significant accuracy of 0.53 using WGS for HX, which was a substantial enhancement over the accuracies obtained with GBLUP models. The research further highlights the benefit of including various breeds in the reference group, leading to enhanced accuracy in predictions and emphasizing the importance of comprehensive genomic selection methods. Our research findings indicate that BayesR exhibits superior performance compared to GBLUP in multi-breed genomic prediction accuracy, achieving a maximum improvement of 33.3%, especially in genetically diverse breeds. The improvement can be attributed to the effective utilization of higher single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) marker density by BayesR, resulting in enhanced prediction accuracy. This evidence conclusively demonstrates the significant impact of BayesR on enhancing genomic predictions in diverse cattle populations, underscoring the crucial role of genetic relatedness in selection methodologies. In parallel, subsequent studies should focus on refining GRM and exploring alternative models for GP.

Single-step genomic BLUP (ssGBLUP) effectively models small cattle populations: lessons from the Israeli-Holstein Herdbook

Comparison on Genomic Predictions Using Three GBLUP Methods and Two Single-Step Blending Methods in the Nordic Holstein Population

GWABLUP: genome-wide association assisted best linear unbiased prediction of genetic values

Accuracy of Genomic Prediction for Milk Production Traits in the Chinese Holstein Population Using a Reference Population Consisting of Cows.

Bias and accuracy of dairy sheep evaluations using BLUP and SSGBLUP with metafounders and unknown parent groups

Short Communication: Single-step Genomic Evaluation of Milk Production Traits Using Multiple-Trait Random Regression Model in Chinese Holsteins.

A comparison of genetic and genomic breeding values in Saanen and Alpine goats

Pedigree and genome-based patterns of homozygosity in the South African Ayrshire, Holstein, and Jersey breeds

A method to obtain exact single-step GBLUP for non-genotyped descendants when the genomic relationship matrix of ancestors is not available

Weighted Single-Step Genomic Best Linear Unbiased Prediction Integrating Variants Selected from Sequencing Data by Association and Bioinformatics Analyses.

Weighted single-step genomic BLUP improves accuracy of genomic breeding values for protein content in French dairy goats: a quantitative trait influenced by a major gene

Comparative Study of Estimation Methods for Genomic Breeding Values

Improvement of Genomic Prediction by Integrating Additional Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms Selected from Imputed Whole Genome Sequencing Data.

Functionally prioritised whole-genome sequence variants improve the accuracy of genomic prediction for heat tolerance

Improving Genomic Predictions in Multi-Breed Cattle Populations: A Comparative Analysis of BayesR and GBLUP Models

Genomic Selection and Use of Molecular Tools in Breeding Programs for Indigenous and Crossbred Cattle in Developing Countries: Current Status and Future Prospects

Validating genomic predictions for economic traits in purebred US dairy heifers

Invited review: Genomic selection in dairy cattle: progress and challenges

Comparing SNP Panels and Statistical Methods for Estimating Genomic Breed Composition of Individual Animals in Ten Cattle Breeds.

Genomic prediction using imputed whole-genome sequence data in Holstein Friesian cattle

Comparing genomic prediction accuracy from purebred, crossbred and combined purebred and crossbred reference populations in sheep