Abstract:Osseointegration of load-bearing orthopaedic implants, including interbody fusion devices, is critical to long-term biomechanical functionality. Mechanical loads are a key regulator of bone tissue remodeling and maintenance, and stress-shielding due to metal orthopaedic implants being much stiffer than bone has been implicated in clinical observations of long-term bone loss in tissue adjacent to implants. Porous features that accommodate bone ingrowth have improved implant fixation in the short term, but long-term retrieval studies have sometimes demonstrated limited, superficial ingrowth into the pore layer of metal implants and aseptic loosening remains a problem for a subset of patients. Polyether-ether-ketone (PEEK) is a widely used orthopaedic material with an elastic modulus more similar to bone than metals, and a manufacturing process to form porous PEEK was recently developed to allow bone ingrowth while preserving strength for load-bearing applications. To investigate the biomechanical implications of porous PEEK compared to porous metals, we analyzed finite element (FE) models of the pore structure-bone interface using two clinically available implants with high (> 60%) porosity, one being constructed from PEEK and the other from electron beam 3D-printed titanium (Ti). The objective of this study was to investigate how porous PEEK and porous Ti mechanical properties affect load sharing with bone within the porous architectures over time. Porous PEEK substantially increased the load share transferred to ingrown bone compared to porous Ti under compression (i.e. at 4 weeks: PEEK = 66%; Ti = 13%), tension (PEEK = 71%; Ti = 12%), and shear (PEEK = 68%; Ti = 9%) at all time points of simulated bone ingrowth. Applying PEEK mechanical properties to the Ti implant geometry and vice versa demonstrated that the observed increases in load sharing with PEEK were primarily due to differences in intrinsic elastic modulus and not pore architecture (i.e. 4 weeks, compression: PEEK material/Ti geometry = 53%; Ti material/PEEK geometry = 12%). Additionally, local tissue energy effective strains on bone tissue adjacent to the implant under spinal load magnitudes were over two-fold higher with porous PEEK than porous Ti (i.e. 4 weeks, compression: PEEK = 784 ± 351 microstrain; Ti = 180 ± 300 microstrain; and 12 weeks, compression: PEEK = 298 ± 88 microstrain; Ti = 121 ± 49 microstrain). The higher local strains on bone tissue in the PEEK pore structure were below previously established thresholds for bone damage but in the range necessary for physiological bone maintenance and adaptation. Placing these strain magnitudes in the context of literature on bone adaptation to mechanical loads, this study suggests that porous PEEK structures may provide a more favorable mechanical environment for bone formation and maintenance under spinal load magnitudes than currently available porous 3D-printed Ti, regardless of the level of bone ingrowth.

Unidirectional titanium fiber-reinforced porous titanium with mechanical properties suitable for load-bearing biomaterials

Printing of Titanium Implant Prototype

Novel fabrication of porous titanium by a resin-impregnated titanium substitution technique for bone reconstruction

Evaluation of channel-like porous-structured titanium in mechanical properties and osseointegration

A novel porous titanium with engineered surface for bone defect repair in load‐bearing position

Properties of Additive-Manufactured Open Porous Titanium Structures for Patient-Specific Load-Bearing Implants

Designing bioactive porous titanium interfaces to balance mechanical properties and in vitro cells behavior towards increased osseointegration

Fabrication of graded porous titanium–magnesium composite for load-bearing biomedical applications

High Strength Titanium with Fibrous Grain for Advanced Bone Regeneration

Assessing Microstructural, Biomechanical, and Biocompatible Properties of TiNb Alloys for Potential Use as Load-Bearing Implants

Mechanical properties and biocompatibility of porous titanium scaffolds for bone tissue engineering

Bionic mechanical design and 3D printing of novel porous Ti6Al4V implants for biomedical applications

Structure and mechanical characteristics of titanium fiber material with gradient pore architecture

High–Strength Porous TiNbZrTaFe Alloys Fabricated by Sintering of Nanocomposite Powder Precursor with Space Holder Technique

Effect of porous orthopaedic implant material and structure on load sharing with simulated bone ingrowth: A finite element analysis comparing titanium and PEEK

Low elastic modulus and highly porous triply periodic minimal surfaces architectured implant for orthopedic applications

Potential Use of Porous Titanium-Niobium Alloy in Orthopedic Implants: Preparation and Experimental Study of Its Biocompatibility in Vitro.

Finite element analysis of Ti6Al4V porous structures for low-stiff hip implant application

A Biomimetic Structural Material with Adjustable Mechanical Property for Bone Tissue Engineering

Processing of Porous-Core Materials for Bone Implant Applications: A Permeability and Mechanical Strength Analysis

Porous material based on spongy titanium granules: Structure, mechanical properties, and osseointegration