Abstract:Background: Long genomic R-loops in eukaryotes were first described at the immunoglobulin heavy chain locus switch regions using bisulfite sequencing and functional studies. A mouse monoclonal antibody called S9.6 has been used for immunoprecipitation (IP) to identify R-loops, based on the assumption that it is specific for RNA:DNA over other nucleic acid duplexes. However, recent work has demonstrated that a variable domain of S9.6 binds AU-rich RNA:RNA duplexes with a KD that is only 5.6-fold weaker than for RNA:DNA duplexes. Most IP protocols do not pre-clear the genomic nucleic acid with RNase A to remove free RNA. Fold back of ssRNA can readily generate RNA:RNA duplexes that may bind the S9.6 antibody, and adventitious binding of RNA may also create short RNA:DNA regions. Here we investigate whether RNase A is needed to obtain reliable IP with S9.6. Findings: As our test locus, we chose the most well-documented site for kilobase-long mammalian genomic R-loops, the immunoglobulin heavy chain locus (IgH) class switch regions. The R-loops at this locus can be induced by using cytokines to stimulate transcription from germline transcript promoters. We tested IP using S9.6 with and without various RNase treatments. The RNase treatments included RNase H to destroy the RNA in an RNA:DNA duplex and RNase A to destroy single-stranded (ss) RNA to prevent it from binding S9.6 directly (as duplex RNA) and to prevent the ssRNA from annealing to the genome, resulting in adventitious RNA:DNA hybrids. We find that optimal detection of RNA:DNA duplexes requires removal of ssRNA using RNase A. Without RNase A treatment, known regions of R-loop formation containing RNA:DNA duplexes can not be reliably detected. With RNase A treatment, a signal can be detected over background, but only within a limited 2 or 3-fold range, even with a stable kilobase-long genomic R-loop. Conclusion: Any use of the S9.6 antibody must be preceded by RNase A treatment to remove free ssRNA that may compete for the S9.6 binding by forming RNA:RNA regions or short, transient RNA:DNA duplexes. Caution should be used when interpreting S9.6 data, and confirmation by independent structural and functional methods is essential.

Apparent RNA bridging between PRC2 and chromatin is an artifact of non-specific chromatin precipitation upon RNA degradation

The apparent loss of PRC2 chromatin occupancy as an artefact of RNA depletion

The apparent loss of PRC2 chromatin occupancy as an artifact of RNA depletion

Denaturing purifications demonstrate that PRC2 and other widely reported chromatin proteins do not appear to bind directly to RNA in vivo

Evaluation of the RNA-dependence of PRC2 binding to chromatin in human pluripotent stem cells

Failing to account for RNA quantity inflates background and leads to the misleading appearance that PRC2 and GFP bind to RNA in vivo

Diverse RNA Structures Induce PRC2 Dimerization and Inhibit Histone Methyltransferase Activity

Re-analysis of CLAP data affirms PRC2 as an RNA binding protein

Structural basis for the inhibition of PRC2 by active transcription histone posttranslational modifications

Complexities due to single-stranded RNA during antibody detection of genomic rna:dna hybrids

RNA matchmaking remodels lncRNA structure and promotes PRC2 activity

Structural basis for inactivation of PRC2 by G-quadruplex RNA

PRC2-RNA interactions: Viewpoint from Tom Cech, Chen Davidovich, and Richard Jenner

Structural Insight into Poly(A) Binding and Catalytic Mechanism of Human Parn

Genome-wide identification of stable RNA-chromatin interactions

Inseparable RNA binding and chromatin modification activities of a nucleosome-interacting surface in EZH2

Structural Basis of the PNRC2-mediated Link Between Mrna Surveillance and Decapping.

The Chromatin Remodeling Complex NuRD Establishes the Poised State of Rrna Genes Characterized by Bivalent Histone Modifications and Altered Nucleosome Positions

R-ChIP for genome-wide mapping of R-loops by using catalytically inactive RNASEH1

PRC2-RNA interactions: Viewpoint from Jimmy K. Guo, Mario R. Blanco, and Mitchell Guttman

irCLIP-RNP and Re-CLIP reveal patterns of dynamic protein associations on RNA