Abstract:PURPOSE: To develop and evaluate an image-domain noise reduction method based on a modified nonlocal means (NLM) algorithm that is adaptive to local noise level of CT images and to implement this method in a time frame consistent with clinical workflow.METHODS: A computationally efficient technique for local noise estimation directly from CT images was developed. A forward projection, based on a 2D fan-beam approximation, was used to generate the projection data, with a noise model incorporating the effects of the bowtie filter and automatic exposure control. The noise propagation from projection data to images was analytically derived. The analytical noise map was validated using repeated scans of a phantom. A 3D NLM denoising algorithm was modified to adapt its denoising strength locally based on this noise map. The performance of this adaptive NLM filter was evaluated in phantom studies in terms of in-plane and cross-plane high-contrast spatial resolution, noise power spectrum (NPS), subjective low-contrast spatial resolution using the American College of Radiology (ACR) accreditation phantom, and objective low-contrast spatial resolution using a channelized Hotelling model observer (CHO). Graphical processing units (GPU) implementation of this noise map calculation and the adaptive NLM filtering were developed to meet demands of clinical workflow. Adaptive NLM was piloted on lower dose scans in clinical practice.RESULTS: The local noise level estimation matches the noise distribution determined from multiple repetitive scans of a phantom, demonstrated by small variations in the ratio map between the analytical noise map and the one calculated from repeated scans. The phantom studies demonstrated that the adaptive NLM filter can reduce noise substantially without degrading the high-contrast spatial resolution, as illustrated by modulation transfer function and slice sensitivity profile results. The NPS results show that adaptive NLM denoising preserves the shape and peak frequency of the noise power spectrum better than commercial smoothing kernels, and indicate that the spatial resolution at low contrast levels is not significantly degraded. Both the subjective evaluation using the ACR phantom and the objective evaluation on a low-contrast detection task using a CHO model observer demonstrate an improvement on low-contrast performance. The GPU implementation can process and transfer 300 slice images within 5 min. On patient data, the adaptive NLM algorithm provides more effective denoising of CT data throughout a volume than standard NLM, and may allow significant lowering of radiation dose. After a two week pilot study of lower dose CT urography and CT enterography exams, both GI and GU radiology groups elected to proceed with permanent implementation of adaptive NLM in their GI and GU CT practices.CONCLUSIONS: This work describes and validates a computationally efficient technique for noise map estimation directly from CT images, and an adaptive NLM filtering based on this noise map, on phantom and patient data. Both the noise map calculation and the adaptive NLM filtering can be performed in times that allow integration with clinical workflow. The adaptive NLM algorithm provides effective denoising of CT data throughout a volume, and may allow significant lowering of radiation dose.

An automated technique for global noise level measurement in CT image with a conjunction of image gradient

Study on the Optimized Scanning Conditions of Cerebral CT Angiography Based on the Angiographic CT Head Phantom

Nonlinear Sinogram Smoothing for Low-Dose X-ray CT

Parameter Estimation and Statistical Noise Reduction for Low-Dose CT Sinogram

Preliminary study of peripheral artery CT angiography with auto-tube current of different tube voltage and noise index

Adaptive Noise Reduction of Low-dose CT Sinograms Based on MCMC Method

Fully automated measurement of noise, signal-to-noise ratio, and contrast-to-noise ratio on chest CT images: feasibility and efficiency

Blind Analysis of CT Image Noise Using Residual Denoised Images

Automated Selection of Uniform Regions for CT Image Quality Detection

Effect of scattering and electronic noise upon selection of detectors for Gamma Computerized Tomography

NoiseNet, a fully automatic noise assessment tool that can identify non-diagnostic CCTA examinations

Adaptive nonlocal means filtering based on local noise level for CT denoising

Fully automated image quality evaluation on patient CT: Multi-vendor and multi-reconstruction study

Development, validation, and application of a generic image‐based noise addition method for simulating reduced dose computed tomography images

Analytical Noise Treatment for Low-Dose Ct Projection Data by Penalized Weighted Least-Square Smoothing in the K-L Domain

Development and validation of a noise insertion algorithm for photon‐counting‐detector CT

A Method Noise-Based Convolutional Neural Network Technique for CT Image Denoising

Study on Analytical Noise Propagation in Convolutional Neural Network Methods Used in Computed Tomography Imaging

Noise Entangled GAN For Low-Dose CT Simulation

A CT Image Denoising Method with Residual Encoder-Decoder Network

A Noise Variance Estimation Approach for CT