Abstract:Microbes face a trade-off between being metabolically independent and relying on neighboring organisms for the supply of some essential metabolites. This balance of conflicting strategies affects microbial community structure and dynamics, with important implications for microbiome research and synthetic ecology. A "gedanken" (thought) experiment to investigate this trade-off would involve monitoring the rise of mutual dependence as the number of metabolic reactions allowed in an organism is increasingly constrained. The expectation is that below a certain number of reactions, no individual organism would be able to grow in isolation and cross-feeding partnerships and division of labor would emerge. We implemented this idealized experiment using in silico genome-scale models. In particular, we used mixed-integer linear programming to identify trade-off solutions in communities of Escherichia coli strains. The strategies that we found revealed a large space of opportunities in nuanced and nonintuitive metabolic division of labor, including, for example, splitting the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle into two separate halves. The systematic computation of possible solutions in division of labor for 1-, 2-, and 3-strain consortia resulted in a rich and complex landscape. This landscape displayed a nonlinear boundary, indicating that the loss of an intracellular reaction was not necessarily compensated for by a single imported metabolite. Different regions in this landscape were associated with specific solutions and patterns of exchanged metabolites. Our approach also predicts the existence of regions in this landscape where independent bacteria are viable but are outcompeted by cross-feeding pairs, providing a possible incentive for the rise of division of labor. IMPORTANCE Understanding how microbes assemble into communities is a fundamental open issue in biology, relevant to human health, metabolic engineering, and environmental sustainability. A possible mechanism for interactions of microbes is through cross-feeding, i.e., the exchange of small molecules. These metabolic exchanges may allow different microbes to specialize in distinct tasks and evolve division of labor. To systematically explore the space of possible strategies for division of labor, we applied advanced optimization algorithms to computational models of cellular metabolism. Specifically, we searched for communities able to survive under constraints (such as a limited number of reactions) that would not be sustainable by individual species. We found that predicted consortia partition metabolic pathways in ways that would be difficult to identify manually, possibly providing a competitive advantage over individual organisms. In addition to helping understand diversity in natural microbial communities, our approach could assist in the design of synthetic consortia.

Metabolic trade-offs constrain the cell size ratio in a nitrogen-fixing symbiosis

Heterogeneous nitrogen fixation rates confer energetic advantage and expanded ecological niche of unicellular diazotroph populations

Trade-Offs Between The Metabolic Rate And Population Density Of Plants

Competition and facilitation between the marine nitrogen-fixing cyanobacterium Cyanothece and its associated bacterial community

Competition and interdependence define multifaceted interactions of symbiotic Nostoc sp. and Agrobacterium sp. under inorganic carbon limitation

Characterizing the plasticity of nitrogen metabolism by the host and symbionts of the hydrothermal vent chemoautotrophic symbioses Ridgeia piscesae.

Nutrient dynamics in coral symbiosis depend on both the relative and absolute abundance of Symbiodiniaceae species

A critical trade-off between nitrogen quota and growth allows Coccolithus braarudii life cycle phases to exploit varying environment

Bulk and spatially resolved extracellular metabolomics of free-living nitrogen fixation

Intraspecific trait variation modulates the temperature effect on elemental quotas and stoichiometry in marine Synechococcus

Coordinated Slowing of Metabolism in Enteric Bacteria under Nitrogen Limitation: A Perspective

A yield-cost tradeoff governs Escherichia coli's decision between fermentation and respiration in carbon-limited growth

Diurnal transcriptional variation is reduced in a nitrogen-fixing diatom endosymbiont

Ecosystem scale trade-off in nitrogen acquisition pathways

Bacterial evolution: Genomics of metabolic trade-offs

Metabolic scaling in small life forms

Evolution and regulation of nitrogen flux through compartmentalized metabolic networks in a marine diatom

Bacterial community dynamics as a result of growth-yield trade-off and multispecies metabolic interactions toward understanding the gut biofilm niche

Designing Metabolic Division of Labor in Microbial Communities

Phenotypic heterogeneity follows a growth-viability tradeoff in response to amino acid identity

The trade-off between individual metabolic specialization and versatility determines the metabolic efficiency of microbial communities