Abstract:Composting of solid waste can be associated with a loss of the agronomic value (nutrient loss), as well as a source of environmental impact through the emission of the greenhouse gases (GHG) nitrous oxide (N2O) and methane (CH4) and volatilization of ammonia (NH3). Additives have been considered as a useful option to mitigate these environmental emissions, but the wider effects of using different additives on multiple gas emissions is still uncertain. Here, a global meta-analysis was conducted using 105 studies with 303 paired comparisons, to quantify the impact of different additives on NH3 and GHG emissions, considering different composting feedstock properties. On average, additives reduced the total nitrogen (TN) loss (46.4%), NH3 (44.5%), N2O (44.6%) and CH4 (68.5%) emissions, and total GHG emissions expressed as global warming potential (GWP) (54.2%) during composting. Chemical, physical and microbial additives all significantly reduced TN loss and NH3 emission; however, the strongest effect was observed for chemical additives under the condition of low moisture content (≤65%), low C/N ratios (≤20) or alkalinity (pH > 7.5). Specifically, PO43− and Mg2+ salt had the greatest mean mitigation for TN loss (68.0%) and NH3 emission (62.0%). In contrast, physical additives (e.g. biochar and zeolite) were more effective at reducing the total GHG emissions (67.2%) compared with chemical additives because of the greater mitigation of N2O emission. Low moisture content (≤65%) or low C/N ratios (≤20) enhanced the effectiveness of chemical additives in reducing TN loss and NH3 emission. Physical additives were suggested to be more effective in reducing N2O emission at low moisture content (≤65%) or high C/N ratios (>20 to ≤ 30). The magnitude of the mitigation of TN loss and NH3 emission increased as the dosage rate of PO43− and Mg2+ salt/superphosphate increased between 0 and 20%. This meta-analysis suggests that an optimized combination of chemical and physical additives tailored to feedstock characteristics and application dosage may be a promising approach for the synergistic mitigation of NH3 and GHG emissions.

Use of additives in composting informed by experience from agriculture: Effects of nitrogen fertilizer synergists on gaseous nitrogen emissions and corresponding genes (amoA and nirS)

Performance of microbial inoculation and tricalcium phosphate on nitrogen retention and conversion: Core microorganisms and enzyme activity during kitchen waste composting

Effects of chemical additives and mature compost on reducing nitrogen loss during food waste composting

Influence of natural zeolite and nitrification inhibitor on organics degradation and nitrogen transformation during sludge composting

Sulfur and nitrogen co-metabolism during composting: A role of sodium sulfide in regulating microbial communities and functional genes

Dynamics of Ammonia Oxidizers and Denitrifiers in Response to Compost Addition in Black Soil, Northeast China

Insight into effects of mature compost recycling on N2O emission and denitrification genes in sludge composting

Impacts of Adding FGDG on the Abundance of Nitrification and Denitrification Functional Genes During Dairy Manure and Sugarcane Pressmud Co-Composting.

Unraveling impacts of inoculating novel microbial agents on nitrogen conversion during cattle manure composting: Core microorganisms and functional genes

Incorporating microbial inoculants to reduce nitrogen loss during sludge composting by suppressing denitrification and promoting ammonia assimilation

Effects of two strains of thermophilic nitrogen-fixing bacteria on nitrogen loss mitigation in cow dung compost

Mechanisms and effects of novel ammonifying microorganisms on nitrogen ammonification in cow manure waste composting

Mechanism of Sulfur-Oxidizing Inoculants and Nitrate on Regulating Sulfur Functional Genes and Bacterial Community at the Thermophilic Compost Stage

Effects of biochar and biogas residue amendments on N2O emission, enzyme activities and functional genes related with nitrification and denitrification during rice straw composting

Effects of adding exogenous microorganisms on nitrogen conversion and its mechanism of action in pig carcass composting

Mitigation of ammonia, nitrous oxide and methane emissions during solid waste composting with different additives: A meta-analysis

[Effects of Physico-Chemical Parameters on the Abundance of the Denitrification-Associated Genes Nirk, Nirs and Nosz During Agricultural Waste Composting].

Effects of Phosphogypsum and Medical Stone on Nitrogen Transformation, Nitrogen Functional Genes, and Bacterial Community During Aerobic Composting.

Enhancing nitrogen transformation and humification in cow manure composting through psychrophilic and thermophilic nitrifying bacterial consortium inoculation

Mechanisms of mitigating nitrous oxide emission during composting by biochar and calcium carbonate addition

Biostimulation of Nutrient Additions on Indigenous Microbial Community at the Stage of Nitrogen Limitations During Composting.