Diagnosis and Severity Assessment of COPD Using a Novel Fast-Response Capnometer and Interpretable Machine Learning

Leeran Talker,Cihan Dogan,Daniel Neville,Rui Hen Lim,Henry Broomfield,Gabriel Lambert,Ahmed Selim,Thomas Brown,Laura Wiffen,Julian Carter,Helen F. Ashdown,Gail Hayward,Elango Vijaykumar,Scott T. Weiss,Anoop Chauhan,Ameera X. Patel
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15412555.2024.2321379
2024-04-26
COPD Journal of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease
Abstract:Introduction Spirometry is the gold standard for COPD diagnosis and severity determination, but is technique-dependent, nonspecific, and requires administration by a trained healthcare professional. There is a need for a fast, reliable, and precise alternative diagnostic test. This study's aim was to use interpretable machine learning to diagnose COPD and assess severity using 75-second carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) breath records captured with TidalSense's N-Tidal TM capnometer.
respiratory system
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Aims to Solve This paper aims to address several key issues in the diagnosis and severity assessment of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD): 1. **Limitations of Current Diagnostic Methods**: - **Dependence on Technique**: Currently, pulmonary function tests (such as spirometry) are the gold standard for diagnosing COPD and assessing its severity, but these tests are highly dependent on the patient's technical ability and require the patient to exhale forcefully. - **Shortage of Professionals**: High-quality pulmonary function tests need to be performed by trained medical professionals, who are in short supply globally. - **Limited Applicability**: In some regions, the use of pulmonary function tests is restricted because they may induce coughing and generate aerosols. - **Poor Early Screening**: Pulmonary function tests are not effective for early case screening, leading to many COPD patients being undiagnosed in a timely manner. 2. **Need for Rapid, Reliable, and Accurate Alternative Diagnostic Methods**: - **Improving Diagnostic Efficiency**: Developing a rapid, reliable, and accurate alternative diagnostic method that can quickly perform preliminary screening and diagnosis of COPD in primary care settings. - **Monitoring Disease Progression**: Besides diagnosis, an effective method is needed to monitor the progression of COPD, as an alternative to traditional pulmonary function tests. ### Research Methods and Objectives To achieve the above goals, the study employed the following methods: 1. **Data Collection**: - Using TidalSense's N-TidalTM rapid-response end-tidal carbon dioxide analyzer (capnometer), 75 seconds of carbon dioxide (CO2) breathing records were collected. - Data came from five different longitudinal observational studies, including CBRS, CBRS2, GBRS, ABRS, and CARES, covering COPD patients of varying severity and patients with other respiratory diseases. 2. **Machine Learning Models**: - **Diagnostic Models**: Three machine learning algorithms (logistic regression, extreme gradient boosting trees, and support vector machines) were trained and evaluated to distinguish between COPD and non-COPD patients. - **Severity Assessment Models**: A logistic regression model was used to distinguish between GOLD 1 and GOLD 4 COPD patients, with the model's output probability values serving as indicators of severity. 3. **Feature Engineering**: - Multiple geometric features and overall waveform features were extracted from the raw CO2 data for machine learning classification. ### Main Results 1. **Diagnostic Performance**: - The best diagnostic model achieved an AUROC of 0.890, sensitivity of 0.771, specificity of 0.850, and a positive predictive value (PPV) of 0.834. - In high-confidence classification tests, the PPV was 0.930, and the negative predictive value (NPV) was 0.890. 2. **Severity Assessment Performance**: - The severity assessment model achieved an AUROC of 0.980, sensitivity of 0.958, specificity of 0.961, and a PPV of 0.958. - There was a correlation of 0.71 between the model's output probability values and the predicted FEV1 percentage. ### Conclusion The study demonstrates that the N-TidalTM device, combined with interpretable machine learning techniques, can serve as an accurate and rapid point-of-care diagnostic tool, particularly suitable for quick screening and diagnosis of COPD in primary care settings. Additionally, the N-TidalTM device shows potential application value in monitoring disease progression, possibly becoming an effective alternative to traditional pulmonary function tests.