Abstract:Background: Understanding how trees develop their root systems is crucial for the comprehension of how wildland and urban forest ecosystems plastically respond to disturbances such as harvest, fire, and climate change. The interplay between the endogenously determined root traits and the response to environmental stimuli results in tree adaptations to biotic and abiotic factors, influencing stability, carbon allocation, and nutrient uptake. Combining the three-dimensional structure of the root system, with root morphological trait information promotes a robust understanding of root function and adaptation plasticity. Low Magnetic Field Digitization coupled with AMAPmod (botAnique et Modelisation de l'Architecture des Plantes) software has been the best-performing method for describing root system architecture and providing reliable measurements of coarse root traits, but the pace and scale of data collection remain difficult. Instrumentation and applications related to Terrestrial Laser Scanning (TLS) have advanced appreciably, and when coupled with Quantitative Structure Models (QSM), have shown some potential toward robust measurements of tree root systems. Here we compare, we believe for the first time, these two methodologies by analyzing the root system of 32-year-old Pinus ponderosa trees. Results: In general, at the total root system level and by root-order class, both methods yielded comparable values for the root traits volume, length, and number. QSM for each root trait was highly sensitive to the root size (i.e., input parameter PatchDiam) and models were optimized when discrete PatchDiam ranges were specified for each trait. When examining roots in the four cardinal direction sectors, we observed differences between methodologies for length and number depending on root order but not volume. Conclusions: We believe that TLS and QSM could facilitate rapid data collection, perhaps in situ, while providing quantitative accuracy, especially at the total root system level. If more detailed measures of root system architecture are desired, a TLS method would benefit from additional scans at differing perspectives, avoiding gravitational displacement to the extent possible, while subsampling roots by hand to calibrate and validate QSM models. Despite some unresolved logistical challenges, our results suggest that future use of TLS may hold promise for quantifying tree root system architecture in a rapid, replicable manner.

Detecting soil hydrological connectivity in a badland area by fast field cycling nuclear magnetic resonance relaxometry

Measuring hydrological connectivity inside soils with different texture by fast field cycling nuclear magnetic resonance relaxometry

Assessing hydrological connectivity inside a soil by fast-field-cycling nuclear magnetic resonance relaxometry and its link to sediment delivery processes

Nuclear Magnetic Resonance with Fast Field-Cycling Setup: A Valid Tool for Soil Quality Investigation

A Fast Field Cycling Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Relaxometry Study of Natural Soils

Can Multi-Element Fingerprinting of Soils Inform Assessments of Chemical Connectivity Between Depressional Wetlands?

Microbial Diversity of Reconstituted, Degraded, and Agricultural Soils Assessed by 16S rDNA Multi-Amplicon Sequencing

In situ detection of tree root distribution and biomass by multi-electrode resistivity imaging

Spatial Distribution of Soil Organic Carbon and Total Nitrogen in a Ramsar Wetland, Dafeng Milu National Nature Reserve

Towards quantification of soil conservation performance using sediment connectivity concept at hillslope scale: proposing a new framework for data-scarce regions

Coupling use of stable isotopes and functional genes as indicators for the impacts of artificial restoration on the carbon storage of a coastal wetland invaded by Spartina alterniflora, southeastern China

Effects of vegetation growth on soil microstructure and hydro-mechanical behaviour

Multi-element Fingerprinting of Waters to Evaluate Connectivity among Depressional Wetlands

Sustainable extraction and conservation of soil resources: New insights through Natural Gamma-ray Spectrometry based Proximal Sensing Method

Chronological Molecular Fingerprint of Wetland Soil by Sensitivity-Enhanced Solid-State NMR

Novel Indicator for Assessing Wetland Degradation Based on the Index of Hydrological Connectivity and Its Correlation with the Root-Soil Interface

Terrestrial laser scanning and low magnetic field digitization yield similar architectural coarse root traits for 32-year-old Pinus ponderosa trees

High-resolution near-surface soil moisture through the combination of Sentinel-1 and Cosmic-Ray Neutron Probe in a Mediterranean agroforestry

Investigation of land subsidence with the combination of distributed fiber optics sensing techniques and microstructure analysis of soils

A Spectral Transfer Function to Harmonize Existing Soil Spectral Libraries Generated by Different Protocols

High Resolution 3-D Mapping of Soil Organic Carbon at Field-Scale with Multi-Source Proximal Sensing Data Fusion and INLA-SPDE