Nitrogen budgets of contrasting crop-livestock systems in China

Xinpeng Jin,Nannan Zhang,Zhanqing Zhao,Zhaohai Bai,Lin Ma
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2021.117633
IF: 8.9
2021-11-01
Environmental Pollution
Abstract:<p>The crop-livestock system is responsible for a large proportion of global reactive nitrogen (N) losses, especially from China. There are diverse livestock systems with contrasting differences in feed, livestock and manure management. However, it is not yet well understood which factors greatly impact on the N budgets and losses of each system. In this study, we apply the NUFER-animal model to systematically evaluate the N budgets of the crop-livestock production system from 1980 to 2050 in China by identifying the differences of 20 distinct livestock systems. During 1980 to 2010, the total N flow through the crop-livestock system increased from 21.4 to 49.7 Tg, with large variations in different input/output pathways, due to the strong livestock transitions of production towards to a monogastric and landless industrial system. Different systems contributed differently to the total N budgets in 2010. For example, the landless industrial system contributed 67% of livestock product N output, but accounted for 80% of total mineral N fertilizer use and feed N imports by the whole crop-livestock system. The mixed system has the highest rate of N use efficiency at system level due to high dependence on recycled N. N losses were diversely distributed by different systems, with the mixed ruminant system responsible for the majority of NH<sub>3</sub>–N emission in livestock production, and the grazing ruminant system dominant in NO<sub>3</sub>–N losses in feed production. The total N entering the crop-livestock system is estimated to be 53.9 Tg with total N losses of 41.3 Tg in 2050 under a business-as-usual scenario. However, this amount could be significantly decreased through combined measures that indicate a considerable potential for future improvements. Overall, our results provide new insights into N use and the management of livestock production.</p>
environmental sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores the nitrogen (N) budget and loss in different crop-livestock systems in China and attempts to address the following issues: 1. **Understanding the differences in nitrogen flows in different crop-livestock systems**: The study quantifies the changes in nitrogen flows in China's crop-livestock systems from 1980 to 2010, aiming to reveal the differences in nitrogen flows between different production systems. 2. **Revealing the nitrogen budget of different livestock systems**: By distinguishing different livestock subsystems (such as grazing, mixed traditional, and landless industrialized systems), the study deeply analyzes the characteristics of these systems in terms of nitrogen input, output, and nitrogen use efficiency. 3. **Exploring future sustainable nitrogen management strategies**: Based on the understanding of the current nitrogen budget, the paper also explores solutions under different scenarios that may be adopted by 2050 to achieve more sustainable nitrogen management. Specifically, the key findings of the paper include: - From 1980 to 2010, the total nitrogen flow in crop-livestock systems increased significantly, which is closely related to the rapid transformation of livestock production. - There are significant differences in the contribution of different types of livestock systems to the total nitrogen budget. For example, the landless industrialized system contributed a large amount of nitrogen output from livestock products in 2010, but it also accounted for the largest share of mineral fertilizer and feed imports in the entire system. - Nitrogen use efficiency (NUE) shows different patterns among different systems. The mixed traditional system, due to its high reliance on recycled nitrogen, has the highest nitrogen use efficiency at the system level. - The study also analyzes the contribution of different systems to nitrogen loss, pointing out that comprehensive measures can significantly reduce future nitrogen loss. In summary, this research not only provides new insights into nitrogen flows in China's crop-livestock systems but also offers guidance for achieving more sustainable nitrogen management in the future.