Abstract:Climate change is forecasted to increase the variability of weather conditions and the frequency of extreme events. Due to potential adverse impacts on crop yields it will have implications for demand of agricultural risk management instruments and farmers’ adaptation strategies. Evidence on climate change impacts on crop yield variability and estimates of production risk from farm surveys in Australia, Canada and Spain, are used to analyse the policy choice between three different types of insurance (individual, area-yield and weather index) and ex post payments. The results are found to be subject to strong uncertainties and depend on the risk profile of different farmers and locations; the paper provides several insights on how to analyse these complexities. In general, area yield performs best more often across our countries and scenarios, in particular for the baseline and marginal climate change (without increases in extreme events). However, area yield can be very expensive if farmers have limited information on how climate change affects yields (misalignment in expectations), and particularly so under extreme climate change scenarios. In these more challenging cases, ex post payments perform well to increase low incomes when the risk is systemic like in Australia; Weather index performs well to reduce the welfare costs of risks when the correlation between yields and index is increased by the extreme events. The paper also analyses the robustness of different instruments in the face of limited knowledge of the probabilities of different climate change scenarios; highlighting that this added layer of uncertainty could be overcome to provide sound policy advice under uncertainties introduced by climate change. The role of providing information to farmers on impacts of climate change emerges as a crucial result of this paper as indicated by the significantly higher budgetary expenditures occurring across all instruments when farmers’ expectations are misaligned relative to actual impacts of climate change.

Climate change, adaptation, and agricultural output

Adaptation to Temperature Extremes in Chinese Agriculture, 1981 to 2010

Effect of Climate Change Induced Agricultural Risk on Land Use in Chinese Small Farms: Implications for Adaptation Strategy

Empirical modeling of agricultural climate risk

Crop Yield Loss Risk Is Modulated by Anthropogenic Factors

The effect of climate change on crop yield anomaly in Europe

Impact of climate change adaptation on farm productivity and household welfare

How the Black Swan damages the harvest: Extreme weather events and the fragility of agriculture in development countries

Farmers' Adaptation to Extreme Weather Events Through Farm Management and Its Impacts on the Mean and Risk of Rice Yield in China

A meta-analysis of crop yield under climate change and adaptation

Response of Wheat, Maize, and Rice to Changes in Temperature, Precipitation, CO2 Concentration, and Uncertainty Based on Crop Simulation Approaches

Climate Change Impacts on Agricultural Production and Crop Disaster Area in China

Influence of extreme weather disasters on global crop production

Response and adaptation of agriculture to climate change: Evidence from China

Adaptation Strategies Strongly Reduce the Future Impacts of Climate Change on Simulated Crop Yields

The effect of day-to-day temperature variability on agricultural productivity

Agricultural risk management policies under climate uncertainty

Climate Change and Agriculture: Impact and Adaptation

Crop Vulnerability to Weather and Climate Risk: Analysis of Interacting Systems and Adaptation Efficacy for Sustainable Crop Production

Crop yield and production responses to climate disasters in China

Adaptive Irrigation Measures in Response to Extreme Weather Events: Empirical Evidence from the North China Plain