A Genetics-First Approach to Dissecting the Heterogeneity of Autism: Phenotypic Comparison of Autism Risk Copy Number Variants
Samuel J R A Chawner,Joanne L Doherty,Richard J L Anney,Kevin M Antshel,Carrie E Bearden,Raphael Bernier,Wendy K Chung,Caitlin C Clements,Sarah R Curran,Goran Cuturilo,Ania M Fiksinski,Louise Gallagher,Robin P Goin-Kochel,Raquel E Gur,Ellen Hanson,Sebastien Jacquemont,Wendy R Kates,Leila Kushan,Anne M Maillard,Donna M McDonald-McGinn,Marina Mihaljevic,Judith S Miller,Hayley Moss,Milica Pejovic-Milovancevic,Robert T Schultz,LeeAnne Green-Snyder,Jacob A Vorstman,Tara L Wenger,IMAGINE-ID Consortium,Jeremy Hall,Michael J Owen,Marianne B M van den Bree,Kate Baker,Eleanor Dewhurst,Amy Lafont,F Lucy Raymond,Terry Shirley,Hayley Tilley,Husne Timur,Catherine Titterton,Neil Walker,Sarah Wallwork,Francesca Wicks,Zheng Ye,Marie Erwood,Sophie Andrews,Philippa Birch,Samantha Bowen,Karen Bradley,Aimee Challenger,Samuel Chawner,Andrew Cuthbert,Peter Holmans,Sarah Law,Nicola Lewis,Sinead Morrison,Michael Owen,Sinead Ray,Matthew Sopp,Molly Tong,Marianne van den Bree,Nadia Coscini,Sarah Davies,Spiros Denaxas,Hayley Denyer,Nasrtullah Fatih,Manoj Juj,Ellie Kerry,Anna Lucock,William Mandy,Frida Printzlau,David Skuse,Ramya Srinivasan,Susan Walker,Alice Watkins,Jeanne Wolstencroft,Beverly Searle,Anna Pelling,John Dean,Lisa Robertson,Denise Williams,Alan Donaldson,Lucy Raymond,Annie Procter,Jonathan Berg,Yanick Crow,Anne Lampe,Julia Rankin,Shelagh Joss,Lyn Chitty,Frances Flinter,Muriel Holder,Alison Kraus,Julian Barwell,Pradeep Vasudevan,Astrid Weber,William Newman,Miranda Splitt,Virginia Clowes,Fleur van Dijk,Rachel Harrison,Usha Kini,Oliver Quarrell,Diana Baralle,Sahar Mansour
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ajp.2020.20010015
2021-01-01
Abstract:Objective: Certain copy number variants (CNVs) greatly increase the risk of autism. The authors conducted a genetics-first study to investigate whether heterogeneity in the clinical presentation of autism is underpinned by specific genotype-phenotype relationships. Methods: This international study included 547 individuals (mean age, 12.3 years [SD=4.2], 54% male) who were ascertained on the basis of having a genetic diagnosis of a rare CNV associated with high risk of autism (82 16p11.2 deletion carriers, 50 16p11.2 duplication carriers, 370 22q11.2 deletion carriers, and 45 22q11.2 duplication carriers), as well as 2,027 individuals (mean age, 9.1 years [SD=4.9], 86% male) with autism of heterogeneous etiology. Assessments included the Autism Diagnostic Interview-Revised and IQ testing. Results: The four genetic variant groups differed in autism symptom severity, autism subdomain profile, and IQ profile. However, substantial variability was observed in phenotypic outcome in individual genetic variant groups (74%-97% of the variance, depending on the trait), whereas variability between groups was low (1%-21%, depending on the trait). CNV carriers who met autism criteria were compared with individuals with heterogeneous autism, and a range of profile differences were identified. When clinical cutoff scores were applied, 54% of individuals with one of the four CNVs who did not meet full autism diagnostic criteria had elevated levels of autistic traits. Conclusions: Many CNV carriers do not meet full diagnostic criteria for autism but nevertheless meet clinical cutoffs for autistic traits. Although profile differences between variants were observed, there is considerable variability in clinical symptoms in the same variant.