Identifying Critical Evidence Gaps in Wound Closure and Incision Management After Total Knee Arthroplasty: Delphi Panel Insights
Margaret H Ainslie-Garcia,Lucas A Anderson,Benjamin V Bloch,Tim N Board,Antonia F Chen,Samantha Craigie,Walter Danker 3rd,Najmuddin Gunja,James Harty,Victor H Hernandez,Kate Lebedeva,Daniel Hameed,Michael A Mont,Ryan M Nunley,Javad Parvizi,Carsten Perka,Nicolas S Piuzzi,Ola Rolfson,Joshua Rychlik,Emilio Romanini,Pablo Sanz-Ruiz,Rafael J Sierra,Linda Suleiman,Eleftherios Tsiridis,Pascal-André Vendittoli,Helge Wangen,Luigi Zagra
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.arth.2024.06.057
2024-07-06
Abstract:Background: Effective surgical wound management in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is crucial for optimal healing and patient outcomes. Despite surgical advances, managing wounds to prevent complications remains challenging. This study aimed to identify and address evidence gaps in TKA wound management, including preoperative optimization, intraoperative options, and postoperative complication avoidance. Addressing these issues is vital for patient recovery and surgical success. Methods: This study used the Delphi method with 20 experienced orthopedic surgeons from Europe and North America. Conducted from April to September 2023, the process involved three stages: an initial electronic survey, a virtual meeting, and a concluding electronic survey. The panel reviewed and reached a consensus on 26 statements about TKA wound management based on a comprehensive literature review. Additionally, the panel aimed to identify critical evidence gaps in wound management practices. Results: The panel achieved consensus on various wound management practices but highlighted significant evidence gaps. Consensus was reached on wound closure methods, including mesh-adhesive dressings, skin glue, staples, barbed sutures, and negative pressure wound therapy. However, further evidence is needed to address the cost-effectiveness of these methods and develop best practices for patient outcomes. Identifying these gaps highlights the need for more research to improve TKA wound care. Conclusions: Identifying major evidence gaps underscores the need for targeted research in TKA wound management. Addressing these gaps is crucial for developing effective, efficient, and patient-friendly wound care strategies. Future research should focus on comparative effectiveness studies and developing guidelines for emerging technologies. Bridging these gaps could improve patient outcomes, reduce complications, and enhance TKA surgery success.