Abstract:While sustainability was introduced as a game-changing idea, it has often been criticized for its vagueness and its over-accommodating bent toward powerful, vested interests, economic growth, and profit seeking—or, on the contrary, for not being able to enter mainstream politics. As a result, in the current political climate, sustainability policies seem to be everywhere, but so does the social and ecological critique of these policies. In this article, we articulate the seeds of an emerging cross-sectoral shift away from sustainability and toward social-ecological justice. Coming from a multidisciplinary background, we explore commonalities in the shortcomings of sustainability agendas and identify discursive barriers to change across three critical fields: transport, energy, and urban greening. Within each of these fields, we observe an upswing of scholarly work addressing the pitfalls and trade-offs of sustainability, but we also show how taboos and naturalizations embedded in these fields hinder adequately questioning the economy’s role in sustainability thinking and action. To develop our argument that there is an emerging cross-sectoral push away from sustainability agendas and toward social-ecological justice goals, we briefly examine the current state of the wider sustainability discourse together with its critique from a social and ecological justice angle. We then review relevant academic work across the applied fields of transport, energy, and urban greening, focusing on the normative and analytical aspects dealt with, and how they address and conceptualize tensions between the different dimensions of sustainability. In the concluding section, we highlight how a focus on sectoral and local tensions between ecological, economic, and social policy goals uncovers the ways in which injustices or environmental degradation are continually reproduced, despite the sustainability framework. We conclude with suggestions for thinking and acting under the umbrella of social-ecological justice.

Democratic discrepancies in urban sustainable development

Consequential urban development of sustainable strategies

Dreaming the Wrong Dream: an Exploratory Case Study of a Policy Change Toward Sustainable Urban Development in a Medium-Sized Chinese City

Ecological and societal trade-offs of living a good, safe and green life in urban ecological enclaves

Can democracy accelerate sustainability transformations? Policy coherence for participatory co-existence

Urban sustainability in an age of enduring inequalities: Advancing theory and ecometrics for the 21st-century city

Do Larger Cities Enjoy Better Green Space Accessibility? Evidence from China

Sustainability’s forgotten third E: what influences local government actions on social equity?

Urban sustainability and environmental justice: evaluating the linkages in public planning/policy discourse

The urban desirability paradox: U.K. urban-rural differences in well-being, social satisfaction, and economic satisfaction

Environmental Sustainability in Developing Countries: Does Democracy Matter?

Progressive cities: Urban–rural polarisation of social values and economic development around the world

From sustainable development to social-ecological justice: Addressing taboos and naturalizations in order to shift perspective

Analyzing sustainable development in Chinese cities: A focus on land use efficiency in production-living-ecological aspects

Uneven development of the sustainable city: shifting capital in Portland, Oregon

Rethinking the Relationship Between Urban Development, Local Health and Global Sustainability

Data-driven comparison of urban sustainability towards sustainable urban development under sustainable development goals (SDGs): a review based on bibliometric analysis

Quantifying the Demographic Distribution Characteristics of Ecological Space Quality to Achieve Urban Agglomeration Sustainability

Constructing the narrative of the sustainability fix: Sustainability, social justice and representation in Austin, TX

Pursuing Urban Sustainability in Dynamic Balance Based on the DPSIR Framework: Evidence from Six Chinese Cities

Tracing sustainability meanings in Rosendal: interrogating an unjust urban sustainability discourse and introducing alternative perspectives