Development assistance, donor–recipient dynamic, and domestic policy: a case study of two health interventions supported by World Bank–UK and Global Fund in China

Aidan Huang,Yingxi Zhao,Chunkai Cao,Mohan Lyu,Kun Tang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s41256-024-00344-3

2024-02-04

Global Health Research and Policy

Abstract:Abstract Background This study views sustainability after the exit of development assistance for health (DAH) as a shared responsibility between donors and recipients and sees transitioning DAH-supported interventions into domestic health policy as a pathway to this sustainability. It aims to uncover and understand the reemergent aspects of the donor–recipient dynamic in DAH and how they contribute to formulating domestic health policy and post-DAH sustainability. Methods We conducted a case study on two DAH-supported interventions: medical financial assistance in the Basic Health Services Project supported by the World Bank and UK (1998–2007) and civil society engagement in the HIV/AIDS Rolling Continuation Channel supported by the Global Fund (2010–2013) in China. From December 2021 to December 2022, we analyzed 129 documents and interviewed 46 key informants. Our data collection and coding were guided by a conceptual framework based on Walt and Gilson’s health policy analysis model and the World Health Organization’s health system building blocks. We used process tracing for analysis. Results According to the collected data, our case study identified three reemergent, interrelated aspects of donor–recipient dynamics: different preferences and compromise, partnership dialogues, and responsiveness to the changing context. In the case of medical financial assistance, the dynamic was characterized by long-term commitment to addressing local needs, on-site mutual learning and understanding, and local expertise cultivation and knowledge generation, enabling proactive responses to the changing context. In contrast, the dynamic in the case of HIV/AIDS civil society engagement marginalized genuine civil society engagement, lacked sufficient dialogue, and exhibited a passive response to the context. These differences led to varying outcomes in transnational policy diffusion and sustainability of DAH-supported interventions between the cases. Conclusions Given the similarities in potential alternative factors observed in the two cases, we emphasize the significance of the donor–recipient dynamic in transnational policy diffusion through DAH. The study implies that achieving post-DAH sustainability requires a balance between donor priorities and recipient ownership to address local needs, partnership dialogues for mutual understanding and learning, and collaborative international–domestic expert partnerships to identify and respond to contextual enablers and barriers.

public, environmental & occupational health

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to explore how the dynamic relationship between donors and recipients in Development Assistance for Health (DAH) affects the formulation of domestic health policies, and to reveal the role of this dynamic relationship in achieving the sustainability of DAH - supported interventions. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following issues:

1. **Dynamic relationship between donors and recipients**: The research analyzes the re - emerging aspects of interaction between donors and recipients, including different preferences and compromises, partner dialogues, and responses to changing environments.

2. **How these aspects of interaction affect the formulation of domestic health policies**: Through case studies, the paper explores how these interactions promote or impede the integration of DAH - supported interventions into domestic health policies to achieve sustainability.

3. **Achieving the sustainability of DAH - supported interventions**: The paper emphasizes that achieving sustainability after DAH withdrawal requires donors and recipients to share the responsibility, ensure that local needs are met, promote mutual understanding and learning through partnership dialogues, and establish expert partnerships through international cooperation to address the facilitators and barriers in the context.

### Research background

Globally, DAH has played an important role in shaping the health policies of many low - and middle - income countries. However, the influence of donors may lead to the weakening of local capabilities or the distortion of priorities, thereby exacerbating health inequalities. Therefore, the paper argues that achieving the sustainability of DAH - supported interventions depends not only on continuous financial support but also on effective interaction between donors and recipients to ensure that the interventions can adapt to local conditions and be integrated into domestic health policies.

### Research methods

To explore these issues, the paper adopts case studies of two DAH - supported projects in China:

- **The basic medical service project supported by the World Bank and the UK DFID (1998 - 2007)**: The focus is on medical financial assistance.
- **The Global Fund - supported AIDS prevention and control rolling continuation channel (2010 - 2013)**: The focus is on civil society participation.

By analyzing 129 documents and interviewing 46 key informants, the research team conducted in - depth analysis using the process - tracing method. The research results reveal the complex interaction relationship between donors and recipients and its impact on domestic health policies.

### Conclusion

The research finds that the dynamic relationship between donors and recipients plays a key role in transnational policy diffusion. To achieve the sustainability of DAH - supported interventions, it is necessary to balance the priorities of donors and the autonomy of recipients, strengthen partnership dialogues, and establish expert partnerships through international cooperation to identify and address the facilitators and barriers in the context.